According to Le Monde, France's food safety agency may have buried an expert opinion on glyphosate, while a French NGO is calling into question the European assessment report on the herbicide. According to Le Monde, France's food safety agency may have buried an expert opinion on glyphosate. And a French NGO is calling into question the European assessment report on the herbicide.
According to information gathered by the French daily Le Monde, the French National Agency for Food Safety (Anses) may have buried a report on glyphosate, one of the most widely used synthetic pesticides in agriculture worldwide and also one of the most controversial.
Le Monde: "Anses buried an expert opinion on glyphosate"
The newspaper reconstructs the story from 2015, when the International Agency for Research on Cancer (Iarc) classified glyphosate as a probable human carcinogen. Two weeks after this assessment, five French ministries questioned Anses on the matter. The agency then brought together a group of external researchers, asking them to clarify the difference between the conclusions drawn by Iarc and those of a preliminary European expert opinion that found no genotoxic properties in glyphosate or in the herbicides containing it.
In February 2016, Anses published the first part of the expert opinion, containing the arguments both for and against the classification of pure glyphosate as a probable carcinogen; while the second part, concerning the robustness of the tests used in the preliminary European expert opinion, was allegedly buried by the agency, according to the investigation. This is an unprecedented situation: "Normally, an expert opinion cannot be halted for any reason. This is a guarantee of independence: once a question has been put to scientists, the agency must not be able to ignore the answer they give," a Le Monde source declared.
"99 per cent of studies on glyphosate deemed irrelevant or unreliable by the preliminary European report"
Meanwhile, the public consultation on glyphosate launched by Efsa, the European Food Safety Authority, and Echa, the European Chemicals Agency, on the renewal assessment report for glyphosate (drawn up by the assessment group comprising France, Hungary, the Netherlands and Sweden) will close on 24 November. The European Commission will then decide by December 2022, together with member states, whether to renew the herbicide's licence for use in the EU.
According to the French NGO Générations Futures, however, this report, which in effect "clears" glyphosate, did not take into account the majority of published studies on the pesticide. Based on the association's analysis, only 3 per cent of the 7,188 studies published in international scientific journals on glyphosate over the past ten years were judged "relevant" and "potentially useful for research". Of this percentage of studies, only 0.4 per cent was considered "reliable".
In effect, the preliminary report deems more than 99 per cent of the scientific literature produced over the past decade on the toxicity of glyphosateirrelevant or unreliable. "There is an urgent need to develop and implement a method that ensures all available scientific knowledge is taken into account in a fair and transparent manner." According to the NGO, the report also favoured industry studies over those from universities.
Glyphosate, doubts over the transparency of assessments
Food — di Carlotta Garancini
According to Le Monde, France's food safety agency may have buried an expert opinion on glyphosate, while a French NGO is calling into question the European assessment report on the herbicide. According to Le Monde, France's food safety agency may have buried an expert opinion on glyphosate. And a French NGO is calling into question the European assessment report on the herbicide.