Glyphosate does not comply with the precautionary principle and therefore cannot be placed on the market. So rules the Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal.
A health product that does not comply with the precautionary principle cannot be placed on the market. The Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal has taken an unequivocal stance, and in a ruling dated 29 June reaffirmed what had already been decided in 2019: Roundup 360, a herbicide based on glyphosate, must be withdrawn from the market.
The French administrative court against Monsanto
It was March 2017 when the National Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health Safety (Anses) gave the green light to Roundup Pro 360, without conducting a new assessment on the grounds that its composition was the same as that of another plant protection product already on the market, Typhoon. In doing so, however, Anses would have "committed an error of assessment with regard to the precautionary principle".
The product is indeed based on glyphosate, the controversial herbicide developed by the agrichemical and seed multinational Monsanto, now owned by the pharmaceutical company Bayer. According to studies by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (Iarc) consulted by the Court, the substance is "potentially carcinogenic to humans". This prompted the demand to withdraw Roundup Pro 360 from the market, expressed in the first-instance ruling of 2019 and now reiterated on appeal. A definitive verdict will have to wait for the Council of State to rule, since Bayer and Anses have lodged an appeal.
Debate over glyphosate in the European Union
"This important decision should therefore lead to the withdrawal of all authorisations for the resale of products not preceded by a specific assessment, and more generally of all glyphosate-based products, given the numerous scientific data showing the health and environmental impacts of this herbicide," argues Joel Spiroux de Vendômois, who heads the law firm pursuing the case.
The European Union, however, appears to be heading in the opposite direction. Glyphosate is currently authorised until 15 December 2022, and in recent months the process required to confirm or deny that authorisation has got under way. As a first step, the authorities of four member states (including France, along with the Netherlands, Sweden and Hungary) drew up a detailed assessment concluding that the herbicide is neither carcinogenic, mutagenic nor toxic for reproduction. There is a caveat, however: according to reports in the international press, that decision is based on studies which, for the most part, do not meet minimum quality standards. They cannot therefore be considered either independent or reliable.
France: Lyon court confirms glyphosate must be withdrawn from the market
Environment — di Valentina Neri
Glyphosate does not comply with the precautionary principle and therefore cannot be placed on the market. So rules the Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal.