France will restrict access to Mont Blanc to protect it

France will restrict access to Mont Blanc to protect it

Environment · ·

French president Macron's decision comes after a visit to one of Mont Blanc's disappearing glaciers. The aim is to protect biodiversity from tourism and climate change. But it may not be enough.

A sea of ice. That is what one would expect to find on the highest mountain in western Europe, Mont Blanc, and one of its most iconic glaciers bears precisely that name: Mer de Glace. Yet, like the entire Alpine arc, this glacier — the largest on French soil — is retreating inexorably and at an alarming rate, losing tens of metres every year.

Macron visits Mont Blanc

And that is what the president of the French Republic, Emmanuel Macron, was able to see with his own eyes when, last week, he visited the Mer de Glace glacier from the French town of Chamonix at the foot of Mont Blanc. "What we are observing is irrefutable evidence of global warming," he said.

Read also: The Alps' glaciers are disappearing. And the crumbling Matterhorn is their symbol

Il presidente francese Emmanuel Macron osserva il ghiacciaio Mer de Glace, sul Monte Bianco
French president Emmanuel Macron observes the Mer de Glace glacier on Mont Blanc, in the French Alps © Ludovic Marin/Afp/Getty Images

The Mer de Glace has already lost 800 metres in the last thirty years alone, reminding us of the grim, unsettling forecast that, if nothing is done to counter the climate crisis, 90 per cent of the glaciers across the entire Alps will disappear by 2100.

Limiting mass tourism

Beyond the grip of global warming, however, this iconic glacier is also a victim of the direct human impact caused by tourism. "Thanks" to the ever-growing accessibility and popularity of high-altitude mountaineering, tens of thousands of people — hundreds a day — venture onto the roof of Europe every year in an attempt to reach its summits and glaciers, leaving all manner of waste in their wake and behaving in ways wholly inappropriate for the altitudes they are approaching.

Images immediately come to mind of tourists on the glacier in trainers, the mountaineer who wanted to reach the summit with his dog, or a member of the British navy who tried to make it to the top with a rowing machine on his back, only to abandon it halfway. And the Mer de Glace itself has over the years become a popular destination precisely because of its easy accessibility, aided by the train that takes visitors directly to its base.

Read also: Mountaineer Hervé Barmasse: "The mountains need courageous people to defend them"

Il ghiacciaio Mer de Glace, sul Monte Bianco
The Mer de Glace glacier on Mont Blanc is melting inexorably: it has already lost 800 metres in the last 30 years alone © Olya Fedchenko/Unsplash

Expanding protected areas

Faced with these threats, and acknowledging that the battle for biodiversity is "the battle of the century for our survival", Macron announced a series of measures: the creation of the French biodiversity office (Ofb), which will be responsible for monitoring and safeguarding the environment and implementing new protected natural areas (in order to reach the previously announced target of 30 per cent of the country); and the restriction of access to the mountain's summit, requiring those heading to the top to show proof that they have planned the trip and are carrying the necessary equipment.

Mer de Glace, 1910-2020.
Voilà pour quoi nous nous battons.

This decision also came in the wake of criticism directed at the Élysée by the mayor of one of the villages at the foot of Mont Blanc, Saint-Gervais, over how a "mountain for everyone" poses a risk to human life and the environment. "It is all very well to worry about the Amazon rainforest, but ignoring what is happening on Mont Blanc and allowing this lack of respect to continue is no longer tolerable," wrote mayor Jean-Marc Peillex in an open letter.

Read also: What glaciers sound like when they melt

La Francia limiterà l'accesso al Monte Bianco per proteggerlo
France will restrict access to Mont Blanc to protect it © Ludovic Marin/Pool/Afp/ Getty Images

Taking bolder action against the climate crisis

While the measures announced by the French president may help, on one hand, to try to keep the wild and inhospitable mountain sheltered from the traces of mass tourism, on the other — that of its disappearing glaciers — mere protection may not be enough. Indeed, to counter rising temperatures and thus slow the rate at which they are melting, all countries, France included, must act boldly and radically to reduce their emissions.

Read also: Unprecedented temperatures in the Alps, approaching 10 degrees above 4,000 metres

Numerous environmental organisations share this view and have criticised Macron's move. Clément Sénéchal, climate campaign manager at Greenpeace France, for instance, stated that "a state's exemplary conduct begins with respecting the Paris Agreement. But the government is limiting itself to insufficient actions." He added that the measures must affect the entire system, such as ending subsidies for fossil fuels. Because glaciers, if they are to be saved, need actions commensurate with the scale of the risk they face — a risk we ourselves have helped to create.