The early drafts of the Ipcc's Sixth report contained stronger and more stringent language on fossil fuel sources, diet and financing for poorer nations.
The lobbies seeking to slow climate action and the ecological transition are everywhere. They are in the corridors of Brussels, where they try to persuade European commissioners and members of parliament not to impose regulations and directives that are too stringent. They are in the offices of the most important international bodies. They run rampant at every United Nations world climate conference. And they even manage to influence the work of Ipcc scientists, the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
The hand of politics on the solutions to the climate crisis
The latest report from the international body could have been far clearer about the objectives the world must set itself if it wants to meet the most ambitious goal of the Paris Agreement: namely, limiting the rise in average global temperature to a maximum of 1.5 degrees Celsius by the end of the century, compared to pre-industrial levels. But politics did not allow it.
Too many interests at stake, too much money circulating, too much short-sightedness among governments, too much greed from managers and multinationals. So, on two issues fundamental to the climate question, the final text was ultimately softened compared to the earlier drafts: we are talking about the phasing out of fossil fuel sources and the large-scale adoption of diets with less meat and more plant-based products.
Political and economic interests behind the choice of words in the Ipcc report
The final part of the Ipcc's Sixth report was published last 20 March. A milestone that concluded years of work. In which experts are clear about the risks: if certain thresholds are crossed in terms of global warming, entire ecosystems could be destroyed, millions of lives would be at risk, oceanic migrations could sweep across the Planet, which would meanwhile have to contend with a proliferation of extreme weather events.
As is well known, the document, in order to be published, requires the unanimous approval of all 195 member countries. And many of these insisted that the most unequivocal statements on fossil fuels and diet be removed. Lili Fuhr, of the non-governmental organisation Center for international environmental law, was able to attend the negotiations, and explained to Heatmap News that "governments arrived at the report's approval session with legitimate concerns, but also with very different interests. This is particularly true for those nations where large state-owned companies linked to fossil fuels operate, whose executives were present in the delegations."
The cost-effectiveness of renewables "deleted" by Saudi Arabia
In this case, the finger is pointed at Saudi Arabia, China and India, for example, which according to the non-profit organisation Earth negotiations bulletin reportedly worked to water down the final document. One of the points on which they exerted pressure, for instance, concerns CO2 capture and storage systems: technologies still very far from being "mature," yet on which an attempt was made to use positive and open-ended language, reports Inside climate news.
Interesting IPCC talks report. Carbon Removal CDR is key for net negative emissions. NGO (CIEL) pushed to add it’s unproven and risky (to prevent the use). France, Germany, Denmark agreed. Saudi Arabia, China, New Zealand, Netherlands pushed to support CDR enb.iisd.org/sites/default/…
In the same way, efforts were made to prevent renewable energy from being praised too effusively. A sentence that read "in many regions, electricity from solar photovoltaic and wind is today cheaper than that produced from fossil fuel sources" was changed to "maintaining high-emission systems can, in some regions and sectors, prove more costly than transitioning to low-emission systems." Apparently at the request of Saudi Arabia.
Saudi Arabia and other fossil fuel-producing countries argued that the IPCC should be "technology neutral" and recommend technologies like carbon capture and storage (CCS).
They succeeded. Take a look at one of the recommendations from the final report:
The vegetarian diet in the Ipcc report did not go down well with Brazil and Argentina
Micheal Thomas, who runs the newsletter Distilled, was able to consult a draft of the final part of the report, in which it was stated that "a vegetarian diet can reduce greenhouse gas emissions by up to 50 per cent compared to the average high-emission Western diet." The sentence was, however, removed from the final version. Due to pressure that reportedly came from delegates from Brazil and Argentina, countries in which meat-producing industries are particularly significant.
Furthermore, the United States reportedly insisted on removing references to the enormous delays that the wealthy world has accumulated in honouring its promises in terms of financing for the poorest nations on Earth, to enable them to adapt to climate change for which they bear only a minimal share of responsibility.
The Ipcc report, in short, while sounding the alarm in particularly grave tones, represents a watered-down text compared to the true thinking of the experts who make up the Intergovernmental Panel. And this is the fault of those who persist in working against it. There is one merit in all of this, however: anyone who may have had doubts about the gravity of the situation now knows that the contents of the document are even more sanitised than reality itself.
Fossil fuels, meat, aid to poor countries: how lobbies watered down the Sixth Ipcc report
Environment — di Andrea Barolini
The early drafts of the Ipcc's Sixth report contained stronger and more stringent language on fossil fuel sources, diet and financing for poorer nations.