The climate crisis hits banks too, with growth down 20%

The climate crisis hits banks too, with growth down 20%

Environment · ·

The damages caused by climate change also affect the sustainability of the financial system. And bank failures will become ever more frequent, according to a study.

What are the impacts of climate change on finance? This is the question posed by the research paper The public costs of climate-induced financial instability published in the scientific journal Nature climate change, which confirms what many environmental movements have long argued: that climate change causes negative effects even in a sector that appears less exposed, such as finance.

banche, finanza, crisi climatica
At Cop24 in Katowice, the World Bank announced its intention to allocate $200 billion to climate change mitigation and adaptation policies © Win McNamee/Getty Images

The climate crisis and public debt

Financial crises are far from short-lived: the ongoing repercussions that the economy has continued to suffer since 2008 are proof of that. Research conducted by an international team comprising researchers from the Euro-Mediterranean Centre on Climate Change (Cmcc), the European institute on economics and the environment (Eiee), the Scuola superiore Sant'Anna, Università Bocconi and the Politecnico di Milan shows that extreme weather events – such as landslides, floods, rising sea levels and storms – do not only reduce consumption and production but have measurable effects on public finances, in particular on the increasing costs that governments face in restructuring the financial system.

On the one hand, climate change can – as is already happening – increase the number of at-risk infrastructure assets and have a negative knock-on effect on insurance companies, through rising premiums. On the other hand, also according to the study, a vicious cycle would take hold within the financial system: higher temperatures reduce worker productivity and corporate profits; the deterioration of companies' balance sheet conditions would in turn lead to insolvencies that, when accumulated, would undermine the stability of banks; the effects would then cascade on a global scale, much like those experienced during the 2008 financial crisis, forcing governments to intervene.

Impianto di estrazione petrolifera
In 2017 the World Bank had announced that from 2019 it would no longer finance fossil fuels. A promise that was not kept © Ingimage

Public debt doubled and foregone growth

The instability of the banking system can increase considerably, and this instability amplifies the impacts that climate change has on economic growth. "With this study we wanted to understand how much the banking system could be thrown into crisis by losses due to corporate insolvency, and by how much the costs for governments would increase for the necessary bank bailout operations," explains Francesco Lamperti, assistant professor at the Scuola superiore Sant'Anna in Pisa and junior scientist at the European institute on economics and the environment, and lead author of the study.

The study is the first to attempt to quantify this effect: bank failures in the future would be more frequent, by a figure ranging from 26 per cent to as much as 248 per cent more. Rescuing insolvent banks would entail a growing annual cost for governments of between 5 and 15 per cent of gross domestic product, leading to an explosion in public debt that could double by 2100.

Leggi anche: Ancora 1.700 miliardi di euro dati ai combustibili fossili dalle banche, in due anni

"We know that when banks are under stress they extend less credit to businesses, which therefore have fewer funds available to invest, further reducing growth," Lamperti continues. 20 per cent of the reduction in growth is attributable precisely to the effects of climate change: so if the probability of business survival falls by around three times, the risk of bank failure doubles.

manifestazione austerity inghilterra
A demonstration against austerity measures in London © Chris J Ratcliffe/Getty Images

Partial corrective measures

Another interesting finding of the study concerns the possible corrective measures that financial regulators can implement to reduce these risks, in particular through risk-limiting instruments designed to mitigate the solvency risk of the financial system. The study highlighted how, in the presence of climate change impacts, the financial regulator can require banks to set a cap on loans extended to businesses — a cap that takes into account climate trends, so as to minimise the risks to which the financial system is exposed.

In short, finance too can no longer afford to ignore the impact of climate change: continuing to do so would mean underestimating the risks of instability at a global level. Financial regulation could play a role among the possible mitigation and adaptation strategies, even if, as the authors of the study point out, the damage would remain substantial.