Reporters Without Borders and the Fox News model: how journalism is getting worse around the world

Reporters Without Borders and the Fox News model: how journalism is getting worse around the world

Rights · ·

First the fake news of the pandemic, now the propaganda of war: according to the World Press Freedom Index, the state of journalism around the world is deteriorating. And in 2022 Italy ranks just 59th.

Over the past two years, dominated by the pandemic, the great cancer of journalism has been fake news. For some months now, however, it has been propaganda's turn — which, after all, is nothing other than the fake news model projected from above. In general, the 2022 edition of the World Press Freedom Index, with which the network Reporters Without Borders assesses the health of journalism in 180 countries and territories, highlights "the disastrous effects of news and information chaos: the effects of a globalised and unregulated online information space that encourages — precisely — fake news and propaganda."

#RSFIndex: RSF unveils its 2022 World #PressFreedom Index

1: Norway🇳🇴
2: Denmark🇩🇰
3: Sweden🇸🇪

16: Germany🇩🇪
24: UK🇬🇧
26: France🇫🇷
42: USA🇺🇸
58: Italy🇮🇹
71: Japan🇯🇵
110: Brazil🇧🇷
134: Algeria🇩🇿
150: India🇮🇳

178: Iran🇮🇷
179: Eritrea🇪🇷
180: North Korea🇰🇵

rsf.org/en/index

The impact of the Fox News model

According to Reporters Without Borders, within democratic societies divisions are growing as a result of the spread of opinion media along the lines of what is defined as the Fox News model — the right-wing American network that, by way of example, has consistently supported Donald Trump over these years — and the spread of disinformation circuits amplified by the way social media operates. And not even Italy has been spared from this phenomenon, to the point that our country in 2022 drops dramatically in the rankings, from 41st place in 2021 to 59th this year: behind countries such as Tonga, Armenia, Namibia, Gambia and Romania, and just ahead of Niger.

At the international level, democracies are weakened by the asymmetry between open societies and despotic regimes, which control their media and online platforms while waging propaganda wars against democracies. With the war in Ukraine as a glaring example — masked by Russian media as a "special denazification operation" — polarisation on these two levels is fuelling greater tension.

The war, a glaring case of disinformation

It is no coincidence that Russia is one of the countries at the bottom of the ranking, sitting at just 155th place (Ukraine, in turn, is at 106th, among the lowest in Europe). China (175th) uses its legislative arsenal to confine its population and isolate it from the rest of the world, in particular the population of Hong Kong (148th), which has plummeted in the index following the recent crackdown by the Beijing government. The confrontation between "blocs" is growing, as can be seen between nationalist Narendra Modi's India (150th) and Pakistan (157th). The lack of press freedom in the Middle East continues to have an impact on the conflict between Israel (86th), Palestine (170th) and the Arab states.

Il presidente russo Vladimir Putin e il primo ministro ungherese Vikrot Orban
Russian president Vladimir Putin and Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orbán © Sean Gallup/Getty Images

But the West is not faring particularly well either. Media polarisation is fuelling and reinforcing internal social divisions within democratic societies such as the United States: the land of freedom par excellence, despite the election of President Joe Biden, ranks only 42nd. The rise in social and political tension is being driven by social media and new opinion media, particularly in France (26th). The suppression of independent media is contributing to sharp polarisation in "illiberal democracies" such as Poland (66th), where authorities have consolidated their control over public broadcasting and their strategy of "re-Polonisation" of private media.

Quest'anno la giornata mondiale della libertà di stampa si celebra con l'estradizione di Julian #Assange dietro l'angolo.
Non vedo l'ora di leggere le vanterie dei nostri giornalisti su quanto sia libera la stampa occidentale.
1)

Europe the freest place, but with critical issues

Europe remains, generally speaking, the healthiest place for journalism. The trio of Nordic countries at the top of the Index — Norway, Denmark and Sweden — continues to serve as a democratic model in which freedom of expression flourishes, while Moldova (40th) and Bulgaria (91st) stand out this year thanks to a change of government and the hope it has brought of an improvement in the situation for journalists, even if oligarchs continue to own or control the media. Cause for concern, however, is the fact that in many liberal countries with consolidated democracies, including Italy, journalists — seen in some cases as an extension of institutional communications — have faced the virulent hostility of protesters opposed to the public health measures introduced to tackle coronavirus. Here as in Germany (16th), France (26th) and the Netherlands, journalists have been physically attacked and subjected to insults and threats of every kind.

Detention of Julian Assange and "alarming" legislative proposals continue to affect UK ranking in @RSF_en
World Press Freedom Index | Society of Editors @EditorsUK #FreeAssangeNOW #WPFD2022 #WorldPressFreedomDay @RSF_inter
societyofeditors.org/soe_news/deten…

And then there is the United Kingdom (24th), which has paved the way for the extradition of Julian Assange to the United States after more than two years of legal proceedings (a case that RSF fears risks becoming "a dangerous precedent for journalism and press freedom around the world"), and Hungary, the subject of infringement proceedings by the European Union over its crackdown on press freedom.

The ranking of the world's worst

The situation is classified as "very bad" in a record 28 countries in this year's index, while 12 countries, including Belarus (153rd) and Russia (155th), are on the Index's red list (indicating "very bad" press freedom situations) on the map. The 10 worst countries in the world for press freedom include Myanmar (176th), where the February 2021 coup set press freedom back by 10 years, as well as China, Turkmenistan (177th), Iran (178th), Eritrea (179th) and North Korea (180th).

Reporters Without Borders secretary-general Christophe Deloire explained that "the Fox Newsization of the media represents a fatal danger for democracies because it undermines the foundations of civic harmony and tolerant public debate. Urgent decisions are needed in response to these problems, promoting a New Deal for journalism, as proposed by the Forum on Information and Democracy, and adopting an appropriate legal framework, with a system to protect democratic online information spaces."

È realizzata ogni anno da Reporter senza frontiere, ma va letta con cautela. Quest’anno l’Italia ha perso 17 posizioni, classificandosi cinquattontesima al mondo. pagellapolitica.it/articoli/class…

The Index rankings are based on a score ranging from 0 to 100 assigned to each country or territory, where 100 represents the best possible score (the highest possible level of press freedom) and 0 the worst. This score is calculated on the basis of two components: a quantitative count of abuses against journalists in connection with their work and against media outlets; and a qualitative analysis of the situation in each country or territory based on the responses of press freedom specialists (including journalists, researchers, academics and human rights defenders) to an RSF questionnaire available in 23 languages. The qualitative element in particular has long attracted considerable criticism regarding the actual reliability of the ranking, which is not based entirely on objective parameters.