The surprising geography of CO2 emissions from cars in Italy

The surprising geography of CO2 emissions from cars in Italy

Mobility · ·

An analysis of the average CO2 emissions from privately owned cars and motorbikes across Italy's 20 regions throws up some surprises. According to data processed by Facile.it, the top two spots in the rankings go to Trentino-Alto Adige (123 grams per kilometre) and Valle d'Aosta (121 grams), which actually surpass Lombardy (at 120 grams).

Facile.it has conducted an interesting analysis focusing on the average CO2 emissions from privately owned cars and motorbikes, which vary considerably across Italy's 20 regions. Surprisingly, it is Trentino-Alto Adige and Valle d'Aosta that are the two regions where cars have the highest average emissions (123 and 121 g of CO2 per kilometre respectively).

The regional data must be cross-referenced with figures on the average engine displacement of vehicles in circulation, which, once again, are among the highest in the country in those two areas (Trentino-Alto Adige 1,644 cc and 1,557 cc for Valle d'Aosta).

Looking at the new-vehicle sector alone, the Italian average is nonetheless good and well below the 118.1 grams of CO2 per kilometre recorded by the European Environment Agency. In 2016, Italy's privately owned cars and motorbikes emitted a combined total of over 55 million tonnes of carbon dioxide.

Average engine displacement of vehicles in circulation by region

To produce this analysis, Facile.it cross-referenced several data points, including the national average CO2 emissions per vehicle (110 g/km) and the average number of kilometres driven by Italians in 2016 (11,125 km).

Region
CO2 g/km
Engine displacement in cc
Abruzzo 107 1,470
Basilicata 102 1,491
Calabria 94 1,440
Campania 94 1,403
Emilia Romagna 117 1,514
Friuli Venezia Giulia 118 1,520
Lazio 108 1,476
Liguria 114 1,457
Lombardia 120 1,535
Marche 111 1,474
Molise 102 1,508
Piemonte 118 1,492
Puglia 102 1,455
Sardegna 108 1,430
Sicilia 96 1,429
Toscana 116 1,472
Trentino Alto Adige 123 1,644
Umbria 109 1,482
Valle d'Aosta 121 1,520
Veneto 119 1,557
Italia 110 1,486
Source: Facile.it

"To be interpreted correctly," clarifies Mauro Giacobbe, chief executive of Facile.it, "this figure must be cross-referenced with the average engine displacement of vehicles in circulation in each region. In Trentino-Alto Adige and Valle d'Aosta, which also rank among the highest in Italy for the percentage of Euro 5 or Euro 6 vehicles in the total vehicle fleet, the average engine displacement is 1,644 and 1,557 cc respectively. Given, for example, the high number of off-road vehicles in these areas, the figure becomes easier to understand."

Giacobbe's words are borne out by the other positions in the rankings, since the lowest places are occupied by regions where vehicles in circulation tend to have smaller engines; at the bottom of the average emissions list we therefore find mainly southern regions such as Campania, Sicily and Sardinia, where cars have an average engine displacement of 1,403, 1,429 and 1,430 cc respectively.

Further confirmation comes from the analysis of provincial data. Here it is Sondrio that is the Italian province with the highest average emissions (124 g/km; average engine displacement 1,567 cc), ahead of Bolzano (123 g/km; average engine displacement 1,664 cc), while at the bottom of the rankings are Vibo Valentia (90 g/km; average engine displacement 1,433 cc) and Naples (91 g/km; average engine displacement 1,363 cc). "It is clear," concludes Giacobbe, "that in calculating the pollution levels produced by a car, one must not limit oneself to the average emissions figure alone. A vehicle that has not been serviced and is maintained inefficiently, for example, causes very serious damage to the environment, and this should be taken into account."