A massive oil extraction project threatens the coasts of Guyana

A massive oil extraction project threatens the coasts of Guyana

Energy · ·

Exxon Mobil announces an enormous offshore oil extraction project in Guyana. Environmentalists warn of the risk of a new Deepwater Horizon.

A new, enormous oil drilling project is putting the coast of Guyana, in South America, at risk. Signed off by oil company Exxon Mobil, the project has been criticised – as the British newspaper Guardian revealed in an article co-written with the American organisation Floodlight – for the inadequacy of its safety measures and for the impact that the drilling would leave as a legacy for local communities.

The safety of the site is so precarious that for several experts disaster is just around the corner. Since 2008, ExxonMobil has begun exploring a vast area covering more than 2 million hectares, with drilling at an average depth of two thousand metres. Off the coast of Guyana, Exxon estimates there are 9 billion barrels of oil. By 2025, the oil giant could reach a production of 800,000 barrels a day. That would exceed by 100,000 units the estimates for the entire oil and natural gas production of the United States' richest extraction site: the Permian Basin, located between Texas and New Mexico. In short, with these figures, Guyana would become Exxon's largest source of fossil fuel production.

proteste exxon
Protests against Exxon Mobil in Dallas, United States © Brian Harkin/Getty Images

Guyana, "a cash cow to be milked"

The main criticism centres on the relationship between Exxon and the government of Guyana, in which the latter is considered "unprepared" to meet the demands of the oil company. Guyana is, in fact, one of the countries with the lowest per capita income in all of South America, and for this reason several voices argue that Exxon is taking advantage of the weakness of the host government to impose favourable and "unilateral" conditions.

Exxon, considered the first company to have discovered a significant quantity of oil in Guyana, will retain 85 per cent of the proceeds: in this way, since actual drilling began in 2015, the government has received just over 250 million euros compared to the nearly 1.7 billion collected by Exxon and its partners. For Exxon, this is a split in line with the market and with agreements made with other nations, but the government of Guyana – following the investigation published by the Guardian – has asked for a new deal to be renegotiated.

The cost of a barrel of oil produced in Guyana is between 5 and 10 dollars less than the global average. For this reason, Guyana is for Exxon "a cash cow to be milked as quickly as possible," as the president of a consultancy firm involved in the Guardian investigation stated: the company has, in fact, begun producing oil at twice the speed of the average for projects of this size.

"Exxon will be here for another 20–25 years", said Vincent Adams, former head of the environmental protection agency in Guyana. "After having made all the money they can and left, we will be the ones who have to deal with all the mess."

Exxon’s oil drilling gamble off Guyana coast ‘poses major environmental risk’ theguardian.com/environment/20…

There is a risk of a new Deepwater Horizon

When you add to all this the fact that safety conditions are not up to the situation, the picture becomes alarming. What is at stake is not only the health of workers, but also that of civilians, the oceans and global biodiversity.

Several experts consulted by the Guardian state that the environmental impact statement submitted by Exxon in 2017 lacks "evidence of the planning and operations necessary to assess and manage the risks associated with high-risk offshore exploration, production and transportation operations."

In short, the safety plans submitted are superficial, and Exxon's project in Guyana shares several features with that of the Deepwater Horizon platform operated by British Petroleum (BP), which exploded in 2010 in the Gulf of Mexico. It is still considered the largest oil spill at sea in history: in just five months, over 800 million litres of crude oil contaminated the seabed and coasts of Louisiana and the neighbouring states (Texas, Alabama, Mississippi).

deepwater horizon
The Deepwater Horizon disaster in 2010 poured 4.9 million barrels of oil into the Gulf of Mexico © U.S. Coast Guard/Getty Images

Two billion tonnes of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere

The extraction of oil from the deep waters of Guyana and the burning of excess gas (an activity known as flaring) would release around 2 billion tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere: this is the equivalent of fifteen large coal-fired power stations.

Exxon maintains that it complies with all local laws and has undergone rigorous scrutiny to obtain the necessary environmental permits. But if this is true, so too is the fact that before Exxon's project, Guyana had no significant production of fossil fuels. It follows that legislation in this sector is relatively untested. Environmental lawyer Melinda Janki is suing the government to strip Exxon of its lease contracts on climate and human rights grounds.

Janki has pointed out that 80 per cent of the territory is covered by rich rainforests, which makes the small South American state a CO2 sink capable of absorbing far more greenhouse gases than those produced and released into the atmosphere. Moreover, in 2015 Guyana committed to reducing its dependence on fossil fuels under the Paris Agreement on climate.

Forcing Exxon to abandon the project is possible

The final word has not yet been said. There is a hope that Exxon will abandon the massive project, and it lies within the company's own board of directors. In May 2021, activist fund Engine No. 1 succeeded in having two of its members elected to the ExxonMobil board, who called on the company to diversify its investments and abandon projects linked to fossil fuel extraction.

Furthermore, in the very same days that the critical shareholders were entering Exxon's board, a Dutch court ordered Shell to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 45 per cent by 2030. So, if the attempt from within were not to work, one can always hope for a ruling issued in defence of the climate.

In conclusion, the project that Exxon intends to carry out in Guyana would cause climate damage that we cannot afford, especially following the alarm raised on 9 August 2021 by the experts of the Ipcc, the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change: the atmosphere of planet Earth has already warmed by 1.1 degrees Celsius compared to the pre-industrial period. For this reason, according to the 234 scientists from 66 countries who signed the report, we must act now against the climate crisis or we will live in a state of continuous emergency.