The Nigerian community of Aggah has suffered flooding as a result of the activities of an Eni subsidiary. It is therefore seeking justice in Italy, where the multinational makes the decisions that threaten its village.
There is another migration from Nigeria to Italy, but it is not that of people fleeing violence and poverty. It is that of people seeking justice and demanding that the conduct of Italian multinationals be judged according to European laws and agreements, rather than in African courts, which are all too often bogged down by local interests, corruption and lack of jurisdiction. Local communities are learning to make their voices heard, also thanks to humanitarian organisations that provide legal expertise free of charge and facilitate access to justice.
This is the case of the Nigerian community of Aggah, in Rivers State, a favoured destination for oil multinationals, which in December filed a petition in Italy and the Netherlands against Italian oil company Eni and two Dutch holding companies, seeking justice over the conduct of local subsidiary Nigerian Agip Oil Company (Naoc).
The companies are accused of having violated the human rights of the inhabitants of this area as set out in the international standards contained in the guidelines for multinational enterprises established by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Based on the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, the guidelines address transparency, accountability and respect for human rights, and encourage the application of oversight mechanisms where these rights are violated.
Despite the difficulty of pursuing companies with fragmented organisational structures subject to different legal systems, this instrument aims to strengthen corporate social responsibility, so that companies are held accountable for their own actions and those of their subsidiaries, even when the latter operate in foreign countries with limited resources or decision-making autonomy – as in the case of Naoc.
The case of Aggah
Eni has been operating in the Aggah area since the 1970s and has built infrastructure such as elevated roads and embankments which, according to many, have disrupted the natural flow of water, causing violent flooding and inundation. Every year, homes and crops are destroyed and residents, forced to abandon their dwellings, are constantly exposed to health risks such as pneumonia and malaria.
"Our buildings," explains Vitoria Elechi, leader of the Aggah women, "are submerged in water and our homes are damaged. We need support and for the flooding to stop." And Blessing Godwin, displaced along with his daughter as a result of the flooding, adds: "We no longer sleep at home, but on top of the table in my shop."
Jonathan Kaufman is executive director of Advocates for community alternatives, an organisation that helps communities in West Africa, threatened by the impact of extractive activities and development based on fossil resources, to plan a sustainable future and sustainable development. Kaufman is following the case of the Aggah community, legally represented by a Nigerian firm, Chima Williams & Associates, with the support of lawyer Giacomo Cremonesi and Dr Irene Salvi, for the proceedings to be carried out in Italy.
It was the local association Egbema voice of freedom, led by Pastor Evaristus Nicholas, that filed the complaint with the OECD, asking Eni to install water drainage systems to put an end to the annual flooding, to compensate for the damage caused and to assist the residents of Aggah whose rights have been violated.
"It is clear that we are facing a human rights violation because, as a result of the company's negligence or actions, people no longer have access to adequate food, their homes have been destroyed, health conditions have deteriorated and in some cases there have been fatalities – all of these situations correspond to violations of internationally recognised human rights," explains Kaufman. "We analysed United Nations documents and treaties and it is clear that what appears at first glance to be an environmental problem rises to the level of a human rights violation. This happens when environmental abuse is so severe that it destroys the resources on which people depend for their livelihoods."
But the problem does not end with the flooding: "Honestly, I am shocked that Eni has not resolved this problem, which is plain for all to see and whose causes have been identified. Relations with the community have now broken down. It is not enough for Eni to fix the problem; transparency and accountability are essential in order to avoid further broken promises." Therein lies the crux of the matter. The solution is straightforward, but the process for achieving it is delicate and must be open and transparent.
Very often, companies entrust the carrying out of works to a member or faction of the community, but with no transparency whatsoever and no opportunity for the rest of those involved to check the quality of the work and its actual capacity to resolve the problem.
A participatory approach is important on several levels and helps the community to become more aware. Among the documents submitted in support of the complaint, for instance, are the results of a survey conducted by consulting 2,000 residents on their perception of the impact generated by Eni's installations on Aggah's livelihoods, health and economic resources.
"What emerges from the survey is a truly tragic situation," Kaufman continues. "Before that, we did not have an overall picture, but thanks to this research the community has a clear view of the situation, and now that it has this information it can use it in its own fight: this is the reality, regardless of what Eni claims." The findings show that, as a result of the flooding, 90 per cent of families have suffered damage to their agriculture and 65 per cent report serious health problems.
The first thing to establish is whether it was indeed the operations of the Nigerian Agip oil company that caused the flooding. The survey results show beyond doubt that the community believes this to be the case, to the extent that it has in the past also paid compensation to residents. In 2015, the Nigerian Ministry of the Environment ordered Naoc to carry out the works necessary to stop the flooding, but when these requirements went unmet, in 2016 the government pursued legal action. That case is currently stalled, but another avenue has opened up: the complaint that has been filed with the OECD National Contact Point.
It is also worth examining why it has taken so long to invoke the Organisation's guidelines. "In truth, it seems to me that at a local level, the people of Aggah tried everything. There are documents dating back to the 1990s that bear witness to complaints, protests, meetings, letters. I believe no one thought it would be possible to go to Italy to seek justice — it's so far away. In the Niger Delta there are very many communities suffering the consequences of extractive activities. This case is particular but it shows how oil companies operate with little if any consideration for local populations. To be able to bring a case before a foreign court, the community must be very united, have very thorough documentation, and must also have had the good fortune of being in contact with international lawyers. And the community of Aggah only recently had that opportunity."
The guidelines are recommendations addressed by governments to multinational enterprises. The guidelines aim […] to strengthen the basis for mutual trust between enterprises and the societies in which they operate. According to the guidelines, enterprises should, among other things:
contribute to economic, social and environmental progress with a view to achieving sustainable development;
respect the internationally recognised human rights of those affected by their activities;
encourage the development of local capacities through close cooperation with the local community […].
Resorting to the guidelines is not a particularly stringent form of justice, but as Kaufman suggests: "This is not an activity to undertake if the only objective is to win. This is a process that must strengthen the community, give it a sense of power, of unity and satisfaction."
In simple terms, it works like this: once the submission is received, the OECD contact point consulted carries out a quick analysis of the case to decide whether it falls within the guidelines, and if so they can offer mediation to both parties. If this mediation is successful, the parties commit to a public statement on the actions to be taken. "In our case, if mediation fails or Eni does not wish to mediate, the OECD produces a report on the situation and potentially a recommendation that however implies no obligation, only an official report by the Italian government," explains Kaufman.
Eni may therefore avoid carrying out the interventions recommended to it, but at that point it would be disregarding guidance issued by the Italian government, which is also one of its shareholders. With regard to this potential conflict of interest, the inclusion of the Dutch OECD representative, who has considerable experience in similar cases, provides an additional guarantee.
The submission was filed on 15 December 2017 and an initial response from Eni arrived in early February but has not yet been made public.
Oil company Eni accused (in Italy) of causing flooding in a Nigerian village
Environment — di Gloria Schiavi
The Nigerian community of Aggah has suffered flooding as a result of the activities of an Eni subsidiary. It is therefore seeking justice in Italy, where the multinational makes the decisions that threaten its village.