Emissions from the world's wealthiest countries are sinking the rest of the world

Emissions from the world's wealthiest countries are sinking the rest of the world

Environment · ·

Emissions from five countries wiped out 11 per cent of global GDP between 1990 and 2014. The countries in question are the United States, China, Russia, India and Brazil.

One of the great disappointments left as a legacy of Cop26, the Glasgow climate conference, is the chapter on loss and damage. The idea was to create a mechanism whereby wealthy countries, historically responsible for the majority of greenhouse gas emissions and therefore of climate change, could compensate poorer countries that bear the consequences. Negotiations were intensive, but to no avail: the text of the Glasgow Climate Pact contains no trace of it. Some months on, two scientific studies go so far as to quantify these damages, naming the countries that bear the greatest responsibility. And, conversely, calculating the costs — sometimes enormous — that fall on the shoulders of the most vulnerable. Reminding us, once again, that the climate crisis is also a matter of social justice.

US emissions have inflicted $1.9 trillion in damages on other countries

Researchers at Dartmouth University, in New Hampshire, were the first to draw a direct link between the cumulative greenhouse gas emissions of each nation and GDP performance across 143 countries. This is because, as Professor Justin Mankin explains, "greenhouse gas emissions generated in one country cause warming in another country, and that warming can depress economic growth".

The results, described in a paper published in Climatic change, are clear-cut. At the top of the list of those responsible are the United States, which alone inflicted $1,910 billion in economic damages on other countries in the period between 1990 and 2014. Close behind is China, at $1,830 billion. The ranking continues with Russia ($986 billion), India ($809 billion) and Brazil ($528 billion). Adding these five countries together, cumulative losses exceed $6 trillion over the same period of 1990 to 2014 — equivalent to around 11 per cent of global GDP during that time.

The US has inflicted more than $1.9tn in damage to other countries from the effects of its greenhouse gas emissions, according to a new analysis that has provided the first measurement of nations’ liability in stoking the climate crisis. ✍️ @olliemilman
theguardian.com/environment/20…

Poor countries will have to sacrifice healthcare to defend themselves from the climate crisis

Another study, conducted by the NGO Tearfund, examines the climate crisis from a different angle: that of African countries doing everything they can to protect their territory and populations. Specifically, the report looked at the costs of the national adaptation plans drawn up by Cameroon, Cape Verde, Chad, the Republic of the Congo, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Madagascar, Mali, Mauritania and Sudan. These were then compared with funds allocated to public healthcare. The finding, in every single case, is that the former exceed the latter. This leads to extreme situations such as that of Eritrea, where adaptation costs amount to 22.7 per cent of GDP while healthcare costs stand at just 4.46 per cent. Or that of Mauritania, at 13.4 per cent against 3.3 per cent.

agricoltura-siccita-africa
In Madagascar, it has not rained enough for four years © Ninno JackJr/Unsplash

What does all this mean? That "African countries must spend money they do not have to adapt to a crisis they did not cause," the report states. "Without greater support, this will likely come at the expense of crucial public services, such as healthcare." This support was promised more than ten years ago, in 2009. Through the Green Climate Fund, wealthy nations committed to channelling $100 billion per year to poorer ones between 2020 and 2025. But this commitment has never been fully honoured.