Emilia-Romagna, after the flood geologists call for serious land management
Rights — di Simone Santi
The president of the Emilia-Romagna Order of Geologists, Paride Antolini: “A genuine reversal of course in land management is needed”.

The president of the Emilia-Romagna Order of Geologists, Paride Antolini: “A genuine reversal of course in land management is needed”.
Two days of driving rain that threw Emilia-Romagna into chaos, a state of emergency declared by the government, and then the first measures targeting the water emergency from the government steering committee, which allocated 13 million euros for works to make the area's canals and rivers safe.
Within just a few days, Emilia-Romagna found itself at the centre of an emergency concerning water, but above all infrastructure and the particular morphology of its territory: a densely populated plain, once a marshland, that needs water for agriculture but, precisely because it was once a marsh, fears its excesses. According to Paride Antolini, president of the Emilia-Romagna Order of Geologists, that is where the problem lies: there is no point in blaming the climate crisis if what is missing is adaptation and land management. Below is the interview we conducted.
Dr Antolini, within living memory, do you recall floods of this kind in your area?
Nothing like this had ever happened around here, but knowing the territory, I already knew that problems of this sort would arise. When I watched the scenes from Liguria and Veneto in recent months, I told myself: "If it were to rain like that here, the same thing would happen to us" — our territory cannot cope with rainfall of that magnitude. And indeed, the moment it happened, the rain put the embankments under severe strain.
Extreme events are becoming ever more frequent, yet you maintain that what happened is not a matter of climate change: what do you mean?
If an embankment collapses — and this time more than one gave way — that is not a climate change problem, it is a land management problem: it is a structural problem with the embankment, with the soil from which it was built, which over time had lost the appropriate geo-mechanical properties (the porosity and saturation of the ground and its capacity to absorb water, ed.). At that point, even during an ordinary flood, with prolonged rainfall of the kind that can occur in winter, the embankment becomes saturated with water and collapses.
Does that mean that adequate land management has not been carried out?
It means that the hundreds of kilometres of embankments we have in Emilia-Romagna need to be monitored and studied to identify any other critical areas, which may result from soil that has become impoverished, but also from other, more mundane things: for instance, the existence of animal burrows dug into the embankment tunnels. This can be addressed through specific interventions — for example, trials were conducted on certain stretches of riverbed in the region where these animals were caught and relocated upstream where they could cause no harm. It worked: then the funding ran out, and the trial ended. In short, there is a great deal to be done, but technology can also help us understand whether an embankment is under stress: there are tools such as probes that allow an embankment to be studied non-invasively.
But has it not been done, or was it not enough?
These are operations that are generally carried out locally, when critical issues are identified. But they are not carried out systematically along the entire length of the river to determine whether it has problems. What I am saying is that a technical structure is needed upstream: public offices that are not understaffed, with the right expertise — technicians, geologists, foresters, engineers, surveyors — who study the problem and intervene along the entire river course to implement joined-up management capable of preventing these problems.
The government has created a centralised structure to deal with the water crisis: drought, but also exceptional events such as the one that struck Emilia-Romagna, which are something of the flip side of the coin. What do you make of that?
I am against a centralised structure — these problems need to be solved locally. Municipalities of 100,000–200,000 inhabitants have the capacity to maintain dedicated offices for this work, which is then carried out in coordination with the Region: together, it is possible to build significant working teams. The person who manages the territory locally is the one who truly knows it. What can a national structure that does not know the territory actually do? It arrives and imposes a vision that may well be that of the Tiber river basin, which has nothing whatsoever to do with the Sillaro basin. Every catchment has its own problems and requires differentiated interventions; you cannot intervene everywhere in the same way.
And the smaller municipalities, which have neither the resources nor the dedicated offices?
They need to be encouraged to join together: clearly, what kind of structure can a small municipality of a thousand inhabitants have? But a union of municipalities can work. Though I'll tell you straight away: the problem is political, because then you have one administration of one political colour and another of a different one, and they start squabbling. Because it is a matter of managing funds that come from Europe: whoever has the capacity to manage those funds builds and creates; whoever lacks that capacity can only complain. Working as I do with funds from the National Recovery and Resilience Plan, I can see that well-structured municipalities are building schools, carrying out works, pressing ahead, while the others struggle. That is normal, but the solution is not a centralised structure based in Rome.
In Emilia-Romagna, for instance, what kinds of intervention would be needed?
We live in a region so densely populated that the moment a river overflows there are houses everywhere and the margins for intervention are extremely limited. Yet there are also less conspicuous interventions that can work. In the mountains, for example, woodland areas must be preserved, because virgin forest retains far more water than forest that is periodically cut. And then there are the embankments: instead of continuing to raise them — the more you do so, the greater the instability — consideration could be given to widening them, particularly on the plain. We need to give rivers space, to try to create what are known as flood attenuation areas or storage basins. When there is a flood, dedicating these areas — which may be agricultural land — to temporary inundation. One hectare of land set aside to accommodate a certain volume of water. Even if here there is the problem that the landowners may not agree…

Would these be structural interventions?
Yes, but more gradual over time, softer, less impactful and invasive than others. They form part of a joined-up management of the situation, underpinned by offices and expertise that do not work only in moments of crisis, but continuously, to rethink the management of river courses. In recent years, however, colleagues working in public offices all complain about the reduction in staff, in funding, and the difficulties they face.
What would the "other" more invasive interventions you refer to be?
The question of dredging rivers, for example — "cleaning" them of sediment. Rivers in Emilia-Romagna must absolutely not be dredged; once they enter the plain, the difference in elevation with the sea is now just a few metres and they have already reached their optimal flow level. There is an entire system put in place by land reclamation consortia that channel the water into collection areas using pumping stations. And still less is there any need to build transverse barriers across rivers to hold back material, as has been done. Also because everything is connected.
Connected to what?
To the sea, for example. After storms we complain that the sea is eroding the beach, that sediment no longer arrives. So when interventions are made along river courses, this too must be borne in mind — namely, that they then prevent the transport of solid material to the sea, and we lose our beaches. There can be specific, particular situations where there are excessive accumulations of gravel, and in those cases yes, but these are very localised operations.
Did this winter's drought have any bearing on last week's flooding?
Look, the Ridracoli dam (at Bagni di Romagna, in the province of Forlì-Cesena, ed.) — 33 million cubic metres of water — was overflowing a month ago: there hasn't been all that great a drought in Romagna. We are always in deficit, that's true, but there has been good rainfall, more so than in Lombardy. And in any case, if it hadn't rained in the Alps, I can assure you the dam would not have overflowed. It's a problem.
Let's hope it has at least served as a wake-up call…
You know it perfectly well yourself: these things will keep happening, cyclically by now — we're used to it. Every one or two years. We have an extremely fragile territory, battered by floods, landslides and storm surges, and every time we find ourselves saying the same things: we need to reverse course in land management. It sounds like a platitude by now, but that's how it is.