This year's Italy is divided between ant cities and grasshopper cities: those that are dynamic and resilient, and those that squander energy by going along with the environmental crisis. A commentary on Legambiente's Ecosistema urbano 2018 report.
There are ant cities and grasshopper cities. Those that are dynamic, do things right and know how to spend resources efficiently, and those that squander energy and money by going along with the environmental crisis without making any effort to counter it. An unprecedented snapshot that shows how good governance, even amid many difficulties, can significantly improve a territory's environmental indicators. The watchwords here are work, planning, rational use of resources, and a long-term vision.
The Ecosistema urbano 2018 report
This is the picture that emerges from Ecosistema urbano 2018, Legambiente's latest report on the quality of cities, now in its twenty-fifth edition, produced with the scientific contribution of Ambiente Italia and the editorial collaboration of Il Sole 24 Ore.
This year, the top of the national rankings is occupied by Mantova, Parma, Bolzano, Trento and Cosenza — provincial capitals that have managed to achieve strong overall environmental performance. At the bottom of the provincial capitals rankings are Catania, Agrigento and Massa. Beyond the numbers, the report highlights the importance of a number of experiences that should be formalised and emulated.
Such as Area C and Milan's shared mobility scheme, the sound waste management of Oristano, Parma, Trento, Mantova, Treviso and Pordenone, the tramway of Florence (and perhaps, looking ahead, the ambitious rail network of Palermo), the water savings of Macerata and Monza, and the investments in solar energy by Padova and Udine. As well as the recipes against traffic and smog adopted by Florence, which is expanding the space available to pedestrians, by Bergamo, which is enlarging its restricted traffic zone to make it the largest in Italy, by Ferrara, Reggio Emilia and Bolzano, which are becoming bike-friendly cities, and by Pesaro, which has built a bicycle metro network.
As regards the performance of major cities, worthy of note is the remarkable rise of Milan, second to last in 1994 — the year of the first edition of Ecosistema urbano — 31st last year and now 23rd. Also notable are the substantial stagnation of Naples, which has remained steadily in the lower part of the rankings over the years, the collapse of Rome, which has fallen back down since 2010 after a climb that had brought it into the top thirty, and Turin, which was as high as fourth in 1998 and ninth the following year, but has since remained well below par. And it is precisely the major centres that suffer most from unresolved environmental emergencies, such as air pollution, road traffic, waste management and water management.
Regenerating urban centres, between courage and political will
The point is that cities are a major national issue that must be addressed as such. Whether or not to tackle — and tackle effectively — problems, inefficiencies and emergencies is not solely down to the ability and goodwill of a mayor. Municipalities must certainly be expected to show far greater courage, capacity for innovation and administrative quality, but at the same time the country as a whole must make a political and economic investment, placing a plan for the regeneration of urban centres among its governing priorities. What is needed is a cross-cutting government policy on the ecological transformation of cities that guides the actions of the various ministries involved, from the environment to infrastructure, from health to transport, through to economic development. On some fronts, environmental policies in our cities are improving even in unexpected ways, as in the case of waste and the circular economy; on others — still too many — there remains a great deal of work to be done.
A selection of best practices linked to Ecosistema urbano will be presented by Legambiente in Rimini during Ecomondo, an event of which LifeGate is media partner.
This year's Italy is divided between ant cities and grasshopper cities: those that are dynamic and resilient, and those that squander energy by going along with the environmental crisis. A commentary on Legambiente's Ecosistema urbano 2018 report.