It is the colour of lipsticks and blushers, of yoghurt and juices. It is no longer in Italy's famous aperitifs. The reason customers took against it? The nature of E120: powdered insects.
It is called E120 and it is the name of the food colouring obtained from insects. It is also used in cosmetics and, far less commonly, in textiles.
The additive E120 is an aluminium salt of carminic acid extracted from insects
E120 is indeed obtained from cochineals, a family of insects belonging to the same subclass as ladybirds, in particular from the females of two types of American cochineal: Dactylopius coccus and Kermes vermilio. Other insects used are Porphyrophyra hamelis, Kermes ilicis, Margaroides polonia and Kerria lacca.
Cochineal is a colouring derived from the insect of the same name, belonging to the family Coccoidea, in particular from the females of the species Dactylopius, Dactylopius coccus, and of the species Kermes vermilio. Carminic acid is the coloured molecule. The females secrete a very dense, intensely coloured liquid as a coating to protect themselves from predators. Producing one kilogram of colouring requires approximately 80,000–100,000 insects, according to FAO estimates. Once the powder is obtained by grinding the harvested insects, it is treated with hot water to extract the carminic acid.
Cochineals are farmed on cactus plantations — in Europe they are raised mainly in Spain. The red substance is present only in the females and is found in higher concentrations in pregnant ones. Cochineals are reared on the pads of prickly pear cacti; the female specimens are collected with metal spatulas just before they lay their eggs and left to die and dry in the sun, after which they are ground to obtain a powder that is then treated with hot water to extract the coloured molecule, carminic acid.
Carminic acid is an anthraquinone glucoside of intense red colour. It is extracted from cochineals with hot water. It is subsequently treated with aluminium salts in order to obtain a lacquer of a brighter colour. The lacquer is precipitated by adding ethanol, yielding a water-soluble powder. Given its high cost and its non-cruelty-free animal origin, it has in many cases been replaced by other synthetic colorants.
To obtain 1 kilogram of colouring, 80,000 insects are needed according to FAO estimates.
Today, all of the most famous food products in Italy that contained E120 have switched to other colorants, principally E122 (azorubine) and E124 (also known as Cochineal Red A, i.e. artificial, or Ponceau 4R). Unlike cochineal E120, these are azo dyes, obtained synthetically in a laboratory. Before their arrival, confectionery products and many other red drinks such as aperitifs, bitters, vermouth and carbonated beverages were coloured with E120 which, today, may still be found in hamburgers, cured meats (products that certainly have no need to court vegetarians), and sweets.
But in general, compared with twenty years ago, products containing cochineal colouring E120 are no longer so easy to find in supermarkets.
Famous drinks and aperitifs no longer containing cochineal
Here is an updated list of some drinks and the red colorants they contain:
Aperol: E124
Campari soda: E122
Ginger: black carrot and safflower extract
Campari: E122
Martini rosso: E150, caramel
Sanbitter: E122
To update and complete the list — or to make sure our favourite aperitif does not contain E120 — anyone can turn the bottles around and read the ingredients label carefully; this must by law list the codes of the additives used.
E120 and allergies
Cases of allergic reactions to the colouring E120 have been reported, and the insect proteins are probably responsible. Indeed, during the extraction process, some insect proteins pass into the colouring at levels of around 0.5%. With a view to reducing allergies, a method has been proposed to reduce the presence of proteins by means of enzymatic hydrolysis. The process results in the removal of proteins with a molecular weight greater than 6,000. Cases of occupational asthma have also been described in the literature among workers involved in the production of the colouring. Like many colorants, both E120 and synthetic red dyes carry a label warning advising against heavy consumption by children, given the possible risk of attention disorders.
Cochineal extract, used for centuries
Cochineal extract, derived from the insect of the same name, has been used as a colouring for centuries, both for clothing and for cosmetics and for food and beverages. For example, alkermes liqueur (from the Arabic القرمز, al-qirmiz, meaning cochineal and denoting the colour crimson, a term that derives from the same word) is an Italian liqueur used in desserts and various preparations, above all in pastry creams. Among its ingredients, in addition to alcohol, sugar, water, cinnamon, cloves, cardamom and rose water, is red colouring, which was originally cochineal but is currently replaced by synthetic substances, E122, E124 or E132. It was in the nineteenth century that chemists discovered how to produce synthetic alternatives to it. In the United States the use of cochineal faces very few restrictions, provided it is labelled transparently as a "natural colouring". For some manufacturers, having a natural, reliable and bright-coloured dye at their disposal has been a great convenience. But its animal origin, and a far from cruelty-free one at that, makes it unsuitable for vegetarians and vegans, and capable in any case of offending the common sensibility, which is ever advancing.
Cochineal in cosmetics: watch out for lipsticks and blushers
Anyone who is vegetarian or vegan certainly knows how important it is to read the labels of the products they buy, not only food products but also cosmetics and personal hygiene products that come into direct contact with the skin.
Unfortunately, cochineal colouring is fairly commonly used by the cosmetics industry to give lipsticks and blushers their colour. It can be found on the INCI label in various ways:
E120: what it is and where the colouring made from insects — cochineal — is found today
Well-being — di Stefano Carnazzi
It is the colour of lipsticks and blushers, of yoghurt and juices. It is no longer in Italy's famous aperitifs. The reason customers took against it? The nature of E120: powdered insects.