The last flight of the plane that swallowed the mothers of Argentina's desaparecidos

The last flight of the plane that swallowed the mothers of Argentina's desaparecidos

Rights · ·

The aircraft used in the “death flights” from which Argentina's desaparecidos were thrown into the ocean has been repatriated to Buenos Aires. The story told by photojournalist Giancarlo Ceraudo, who spent 20 years tracking it down.

Giancarlo Ceraudo answers the phone from a noisy Roman garage, ordering a coffee while waiting to hear the verdict on the state of his motorbike's health. He returned to Italy a few days ago. About two weeks earlier, he was on the runway at Buenos Aires' Jorge Newbery Airport, waiting for the plane he had pursued most intensely throughout his career as a photojournalist: "Seeing it land was cathartic and enormous. Twenty years of my work were right there." That plane was the Skyvan PA-51, which had belonged to the Argentine navy during General Jorge Rafael Videla's regime between 1976 and 1983. The symbol of the death flights through which the dictatorship silenced Argentina's desaparecidos.

What the death flights were

With the repatriation of the Skyvan, the perhaps most painful journey in the country's history came to an end. One that began with the horrors of the dictatorship and continued at history's slow pace. A pace that was never indolent, however, nor worn down by time, driven as it was by the often agonising need to remember in order to achieve justice. It was on planes like that one that, once a week, opponents of Videla's regime were dragged aboard to fly over the Atlantic Ocean. There the plane would open its hatch to throw them where it was believed no one could find them. This is how Argentina's dictatorship invented the death flights and, with them, the desaparecidos (the disappeared opponents), victims of one of the most ferocious and sinister campaigns of systematic extermination of the twentieth century.

Arribo al Aeroparque Jorge Newbery el SC-7 Skyvan N190WW que durante la dictadura militar fue utilizado para realizar algunos de los "Vuelos de la Muerte" en ese entonces operaba para la Prefectura Naval con la matrícula PA-51

"The death flights are perhaps the thing that has been most exported in the world's telling of Argentina's story. A macabre plan that calls to mind Nazi crimes. When I went to Argentina to cover the economic crisis that hit the country, it was 2001. On that occasion I began to ask myself where those planes were," Giancarlo Ceraudo told LifeGate. Together with Miriam Lewin, a journalist who survived the regime, he spent over twenty years searching for the truth about the fate of the five planes like the Skyvan used for the "death flights." And it is thanks to their work that today the plane which on 14 December 1977 threw 12 people into the ocean — among them many members of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo and two French nuns — has returned to Buenos Aires to be put on display in the memory museum at the former Escuela de mecánica de la armada (Esma), the best-known of the detention centres where the military junta held its opponents.

Videla's dictatorship in Argentina

Among the reasons why Gianni Minà will long remain an unmatched master of journalism are those persistent questions — posed on the eve of the 1978 World Cup — about why an ever-louder group of human rights activists gathered every Thursday at Plaza de Mayo, in front of Buenos Aires' Casa Rosada, the seat of the executive, demanding truth for the regime's crimes. In those years Argentina was living under Videla's dictatorship; he had come to power a couple of years earlier after deposing Isabel "Isabelita" Perón.

Argentina
Argentine president Jorge Videla looks at the World Cup trophy during the World Cup final on 25 June 1978 © Getty Images

Among the protesters stood out an ever-louder group of women who called themselves the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo, who openly defied a power that had clandestinely imprisoned their children, many of them very young, accusing them of being enemies of the nation: "In those years the entire human rights movement was rising up forcefully," Ceraudo continues, adding: "The World Cup was on; the regime could not afford to put a foot wrong. So it decided to plant among the Mothers a clean-cut young man who presented himself as the brother of one of the disappeared detainees." He was Alfredo Astiz, who would later be nicknamed the Angel of Death.

The kidnapping of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo

Astiz was part of a highly violent action group within the Argentine navy, which proved to be one of the most efficient instruments of repression during the dictatorship. It was he who, after months of spying, provided the military with the coordinates to carry out one of the most large-scale kidnappings by Videla's methods. Twelve of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo, all belonging to the group from the Church of Santa Cruz, were taken and brought to the Esma. But they made a mistake: among the prisoners were also two French nuns. "The government tried every means to bury a piece of news that would have brought discredit on the country on the very eve of the World Cup and triggered a diplomatic incident with France. It tried to attribute the kidnapping to the Montoneros, a Peronist guerrilla group hated by the regime. They even staged a photograph to prove it, and it is thanks to a copy of La Nación present there, dated 14 December, that we know they were being held at the Esma during those days," Ceraudo continues.

And it is on that very night that Azucena Villaflor, Esther Ballestrino de Careaga and María Eugenia Ponce de Bianco, among the founders of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo, were thrown into the sea from the same Skyvan that has just returned to Argentina. At first their bodies, like those of their children and of many other people before them, were swallowed by the waters. They resurfaced only a few days later on the coast of Santa Teresita, almost 350 kilometres south of Buenos Aires: "An initial forensic report described the fractures present on the bodies as consistent with a fall from a great height. Nonetheless, no case was opened and the bodies were not identified." For nearly thirty years, even after the end of the dictatorship, nothing was known about those bodies returned by the water, nor was any light shed on the disappearances of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo. They remained buried as unidentified bodies until 2005, when a team of forensic anthropologists exhumed them and made their identities public.

The route of the Skyvan PA-51: from Argentina's desaparecidos to a postal service in the Bahamas

"When I asked Miriam to help me in the search for the planes used in the desaparecidos flights in Argentina, she didn't take me very seriously at first," Ceraudo recalls. "'You have a thing about objects,' I told her — I have always been interested in the kind of details they can provide. Over time I realised that the search was more of a luxury I was allowing myself than a gap on the part of Argentines, who were more interested in finding the bodies of their loved ones than the instruments that had made them disappear. But by that point Miriam had already decided to help me."

The Skyvan PA-51 was tracked down in Florida, in the United States. It is the first aircraft for which there is firm evidence of involvement in the death flights of Argentina's desaparecidos. At least 5 planes are known to have been in service with the Argentine navy. Two of them were destroyed in 1982, during the war over control of the Falkland Islands — "Malvinas" to Argentines — between Buenos Aires and the British army. Others were sold to a Luxembourg company in 1994 and subsequently broken up. The only one still in service was transferred to Gb Airlink, a company that has since used it as a means of transport for delivering mail between the Bahamas and Florida.

"When we managed to see the aircraft with our own eyes, we gained access to documentation similar to flight plans. They were all there, including those carried out between '76 and '82. Many were 'strange flights': there were flights of more than four hours, operated up to the limit of their fuel range, that literally went nowhere. They took off and landed at Buenos Aires airport. There was, however, one date that caught our attention more than anything else: 14 December 1977."

The same date reported on the copy of La Nación handed to the Madres de Plaza de Mayo. For years, the whereabouts of aircraft like the Skyvan PA-51 remained unknown to almost everyone. Not only that: the search for those responsible who should have been made to pay for the crime of the flights was also stalling from the outset, owing to the two amnesty laws passed in 1986 and 1987 that guaranteed impunity to all those responsible for killings, torture and other serious human rights violations during the Videla dictatorship. Only many years later, and with the fundamental contribution of the investigative work of Ceraudo, Lewin and all the survivors of those dark years, did the fate of the desaparecidos' aircraft in Argentina begin to come to light.

Argentina
The daughters of Azucena Villaflor and Esther Ballestrino de Careaga – founders of the human rights organisation Madres de Plaza de Mayo – Cecilia De Vicenti (R) and Mabel Careaga (L) pose for a photo beside the Skyvan aircraft on the runway of Jorge Newbery International Airport in Buenos Aires © Juan Mabromata / Getty Images

The trial of those responsible for the death flights

Between 2012 and 2017, a trial took place in Argentina in which some survivors of the dictatorship took part. Witnesses stated that the death flights were weekly operations that came at the end of a longer, insidious and at times horrifyingly sadistic procedure. Often, some prisoners were taken away with the promise of release. They were then given an injection, which the guards and doctors acting on behalf of the junta described as a "vaccination". In reality it was a powerful sedative capable of rendering the regime's victims unconscious. It was at that point — when they could pose no danger to flight operations and could neither be seen nor heard — that they were loaded onto the aircraft that would carry them to their deaths.

Argentina
A man takes a selfie next to portraits of victims of forced disappearance in Plaza de Mayo in Buenos Aires, Argentina © Eitan Abramovich /Apf/ Getty Images

That trial ended with 48 convictions, including 29 life sentences for some former officials of the military junta, while details of the fate of Argentina's desaparecidos were made public for the first time. It was also established that the very same Skyvan had been used to kill Néstor Villaflor, son of Azucena, one of the Madres de Plaza de Mayo, along with 11 other detainees. To date, there have been approximately 290 trials brought in Argentina relating to crimes against humanity dating back to the dictatorship era. All of them came after 2006, the year in which the amnesty laws were repealed. A decision that opened a cupboard full of skeletons and has so far led to 1,115 convictions. Nevertheless, arriving at a credible estimate of the victims of the death flights remains practically impossible, even though, to date, the waters of the ocean and the Río de la Plata have yielded up 71 bodies — 44 in Argentina and 27 in neighbouring Uruguay — according to data from the non-governmental organisation Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team.

"From the beginning of this work I always had the conviction that those aircraft had to be recovered, because they were an important piece — like the Nazi gas chambers, a terrible instrument," Ceraudo continues, concluding: "When I arrived in Buenos Aires I realised that getting to the bottom of the story of Argentina's desaparecidos meant stirring an open wound for everyone, but everything was already clear and simply waiting to be stitched back together. At first, Argentinians would ask me why I, an Italian, wanted to dig so deep into their past. But the truth is that what they have done with memory is something perhaps no other country in the world has managed."