Italy's declining birth rate is unstoppable: what impact will it have on our lives?

Italy's declining birth rate is unstoppable: what impact will it have on our lives?

Rights · ·

According to Istat, Italy's birth rate decline is worsening. The resident population continues to fall: by 2070 it will stand at 47.7 million.

In 1953 Elvis Presley recorded his first single, Queen Elizabeth II was crowned Queen of Great Britain, Alcide De Gasperi appeared before Parliament for the last time to request a vote of confidence (which he did not obtain) for a DC government backed by the monarchists. And Italy's resident population stood at just 47.7 million — the same figure it will return to in 2070. When Cormac McCarthy wrote No Country for Old Men, he was probably not thinking of Italy.

Just a few days ago, Istat published its forecast for the country's demographic future, which confirms Italy's declining birth rate, along with the ongoing trend of population ageing and the consequent future reduction in the number of Italian citizens — or rather, residents in Italy. We are in decline, the national statistics institute warns: from 59.2 million citizens in 2021, estimates put the figure at 57.9 million in 2030, falling to 54.2 million in 2050 and all the way down to 47.7 million in 2070: almost 12 million fewer people.

coppia anziana
Italy's declining birth rate: ever more elderly, ever fewer births © Ingimage

Italy's declining birth rate

In a world advancing at extremely high rates of growth, the decline will obviously be driven by the phenomenon of falling birth rates, which has already been present for a couple of decades. Since 1993, Italy has recorded more deaths than births every year (except in 2004 and 2006), but the phenomenon has intensified sharply: since 2015 the annual gap has exceeded 100,000, and in 2020 and 2021, also due to Covid, the figure exceeded 300,000.

La popolazione residente è in decrescita: da 59,2 milioni al 1° gennaio 2021 a 57,9 mln nel 2030, a 54,2 mln nel 2050 fino a 47,7 mln nel 2070 #istat istat.it/it/archivio/27…

As a result, the ratio of working-age individuals (15–64) to those outside this bracket (0–14 and 65 and over) will, according to Istat, shift from roughly three to two in 2021 to roughly one to one by 2050. Across the territory, within 10 years four in five municipalities are expected to see a population decline, rising to nine in ten for municipalities in rural areas, which are increasingly subject to depopulation. And households will have an ever-smaller average number of members: by 2041, one in four will consist of a couple with children, while more than one in five will have none.

Yes, but what does all this mean?

As far back as 1968, at the end of the decade of the economic boom, Paul and Anne Ehrlich argued in the book "The Population Bomb" that the continuous, exponential growth of the global population would in the long run generate equally rising needs and consumption, causing resource crises and famines. Not only that: even then, the researchers foresaw the risk of an excessive burden of gas emissions. At a time when climate change is now well under way and the ecological transition is a short-term objective, the Ehrlichs had proved easy prophets.

🔴@gigidepalo: «Nel 2050 ci saranno 12 milioni di abitanti in meno. Significa meno forza lavoro, meno consumi, meno sanità pubblica. Natalità sia il tema della prossima campagna elettorale e della prossima legge di bilancio»

👉🏼 bit.ly/3uK9swQ

#SGDN #SGDN22

At a national level, however, at least in the short term a trend such as the one outlined by Istat risks creating extremely serious problems for the sustainability of the state. This is explained by Gigi De Palo, president of the Fondazione per la natalità and national president of the Forum famiglie.

The collapse of GDP and the welfare system

According to De Palo, Italy's declining birth rate will first and foremost bring about the collapse of gross domestic product and, for those who regard that as only a partial indicator of a country's health, above all the welfare system: "In 2018 Italian social spending mobilised resources amounting to 493.5 billion. In 2021 — in the post-Covid period — this requirement reached 632 billion," explains De Palo, citing the Cnel: "The demographic question is the first urgent issue to be addressed for the sustainability of the public debt." As a result, "we will have a country where the vulnerable will be less protected."

The collapse of the pension system

The decline in population goes hand in hand with its ageing. Italy's problem is certainly not life expectancy (which today stands at 84.8 years) but the fact that too few children are being born. "We will have an increasingly elderly population and fewer and fewer workers," De Palo warns. "So we will have a country where younger generations may have no pension at all, or where pensions will be so low as to prevent a dignified life after years and years of work." Even today, the national social security institute, in its 2022 report, warns that the critical age group is that of people born between 1977 and 1980.

👉🏼“Per raggiungere l’obiettivo dei 500mila nati dobbiamo lavorare per rialzare i livelli di fecondità, non per aggiungerlo tra 40 o 50 anni ma tra 10.”

Gian Carlo Blangiardo, Presidente dell’Istat

#SGDN22 @istat_it

Will the national health service become fee-paying?

As already noted, the ratio of working-age individuals — by convention those aged between 15 and 64 (though the retirement age, given the effects of what has been described above, is set to rise to as high as 75!) — to those outside this bracket (0–14 and 65 and over) will shift from roughly three to two in 2021 to roughly one to one by 2050. And this would pose a serious problem for our national health service — sometimes so maligned, yet undoubtedly a source of international pride for its universality and freedom at the point of use — which is sustained by citizens paying taxes in proportion to their income and by the payment of charges for health services by those not entitled to exemption.

Il Servizio Sanitario Nazionale: la nostra più grande conquista sociale da difendere e tramandare alle generazioni future.
#SalviamoSSN
#GIMBE

De Palo indeed points out that "if the number of workers falls (if the birth rate does not recover, there will be fewer people working and therefore fewer people paying taxes), will we be able to keep the mechanism sustainable? Let us also factor in another element: according to current estimates, the number of non-self-sufficient elderly people will almost double to nearly 5 million by 2030."

The housing bubble

One of the most underestimated consequences of the declining birth rate trend, the Forum famiglie president notes, is the likely collapse in house prices. Good news for those who will need to buy, certainly. Bad news for those who already have, perhaps having taken on a thirty-year mortgage. "The value of our homes — which we have paid for, or are still paying for — through great sacrifice will collapse. Their value, after so many sacrifices, will halve. Because if no more children are born, cities will depopulate and, with a greater supply of properties available, they will lose their value."

Depopulated inland areas

Last but not least, there is the question of the depopulation of certain areas of the country. While cities will, even in 2070, continue to be densely populated on average, Italy's declining birth rate will, according to Istat, hit rural areas and the South hardest, where a strong exodus towards the more productive North has already been under way for decades.

Più della metà dei Comuni italiani fa parte delle #areeinterne, ma qui vive solo il 22% della popolazione. Come sostenere il rilancio di questi territori? Scopriamo la Strategia Nazionale @areeinterne e l’importanza dell’associazionismo comunale @FormezPA bit.ly/3uOIq7G

Within 10 years, 80 per cent of municipalities will face a demographic decline. This is due to low fertility, but also to unfavourable migration patterns for certain local areas, where both emigration abroad and internal migration are most pronounced. And for the 1,060 municipalities that fall within inland areas — those in mountain zones and in any case far from the sea, characterised by their physical distance from essential services — Istat forecasts that the demographic situation
will be even more unfavourable, with a population reduction of 9.1 per cent, rising to 10.4 per cent when considering the South alone.

And migration?

Today, inward migration to Italy is seen primarily as a matter of domestic politics and national security — witness, most recently, the election campaign that has just concluded. In reality, from an economic standpoint, the work of foreign nationals in Italy is currently worth 134 billion euros and accounts for 9 per cent of gross domestic product, according to the 2021 Annual Report on the Economics of Immigration by the Fondazione Leone Moressa. And if the trend in Italy's birth rate truly confirms expectations, the contribution of foreigners (regardless of how they arrive or where they come from) will become increasingly important. "We need an Italian approach to the integration of immigrants, who cannot be brought into the Italian project solely to pay for pensions," explains De Palo.