US. Supreme Court weakens the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Biden's climate plan

US. Supreme Court weakens the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Biden's climate plan

Environment · ·

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) does not have the power to regulate CO2 emissions from power plants. That is what the Supreme Court has ruled.

The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) does not have the power to regulate CO2 emissions from power plants. The Supreme Court ruled to that effect on Thursday 30 June, with a 6–3 vote that fully reflects its political divide. The path to realising the climate plan so strongly championed by President Joe Biden, which aimed precisely to halve emissions by the end of the decade, now looks increasingly uphill.

What the Supreme Court decided on the EPA's powers

The Supreme Court justices ruled on case no. 20-1530, West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency, in which 19 states — led by West Virginia itself — challenged the EPA's authority to set greenhouse gas emission standards for power plants. That authority was conferred on it in 2011 — during the Obama administration — by the Clean Air Act. This is the wide-ranging law that has regulated air quality at the federal level for more than sixty years, and has been updated on multiple occasions to encompass environmental issues in their entirety.

"Capping carbon dioxide emissions at a level that will force a nationwide transition away from the use of coal to generate electricity may be a sensible 'solution to the crisis of the present'", reads the ruling, citing a 1992 precedent. "It is not plausible that Congress gave EPA the authority to adopt on its own such a regulatory scheme", it continues. "A decision of such magnitude and consequence rests with Congress itself, or an agency acting pursuant to a clear delegation from that representative body".

Catastrophic. A filibuster carveout is not enough. We need to reform or do away with the whole thing, for the sake of the planet.

A heavy blow to Joe Biden's climate ambitions

"The implications of the ruling could extend well beyond environmental policy", writes the New York Times. "It is also a signal that the court's new, recently expanded conservative majority is deeply sceptical of the power of administrative agencies to address major questions facing the nation and the planet".

In essence, the ruling holds that Congress must pass far more explicit legislation, explains Bill McKibben, founder of the environmental organisation 350.org, in the pages of the New Yorker. This, however, appears "essentially impossible", above all because corporations participate in electoral campaigns and therefore have enormous power to shape the administration's political agenda. This was itself made possible by another Supreme Court decision, Citizens United v FEC of 2010. And it is for this reason that, rather than passing a fully-fledged climate package, Democratic administrations have so far had to make do with certain specific provisions of the Clean Air Act.

For Bill McKibben, the ruling is "the culmination of a five-year effort to ensure that the federal government does not threaten the corporate status quo". The consequences, he argues, risk extending well beyond US borders. First and foremost because the United States has played a determining role in the ongoing climate crisis, being the country that has emitted the most greenhouse gases in history (by current volumes, however, it ranks second only to China). And also because, if Joe Biden cannot lead by example himself, his leadership role in international negotiations will also be thrown into jeopardy.

Earth Day
US President Joe Biden at the Earth Day summit 2021 © Drago-Pool/Getty Images

The United States is divided on climate too

Joe Biden himself, while sharply criticising "another devastating decision that seeks to take our country backwards", promises to press on regardless. "We cannot and will not ignore the danger to public health and the existential threat that climate change poses".

The Supreme Court’s ruling in West Virginia vs. EPA risks damaging our nation’s ability to keep our air clean and combat climate change.

We cannot ignore the existential threat the climate crisis poses. Our fight against climate change must carry forward, and it will.

The three liberal-leaning justices also voice their dissent, highlighting how the EPA has been stripped of the "power to respond to the most pressing environmental challenge of our time". For the Supreme Court, it is yet another politically contentious decision within the space of just a few days, following the ruling to overturn Roe v Wade, which guaranteed the federal right to abortion, and the ruling to remove certain safeguards designed to enshrine the separation of Church and State.

"The EPA can no longer bypass Congress", exults Patrick Morrisey, Attorney General of West Virginia, who led the case, calling it a "great victory over an overreaching federal government and the excesses of the administration. This is a GREAT victory for West Virginia, for energy sector jobs, and for all those who care about the separation of powers in our country".

Some of the responses to our big win today are simply mind boggling. West Virginia v. EPA stands for what should be a non-controversial position: Congress, not unelected bureaucrats, gets to make the major decisions of the day.

The end. #WVvEPA