In a landmark ruling, the Constitutional Court has established that all victims of violence may access free legal assistance, through state-funded legal aid.
All victims of violence in Italy will be able to access free legal assistance. This is what the Italian Constitutional Court established on 11 January 2021 with a landmark ruling. The aim is to support all victims of any violent crime (violence against women, domestic violence, violence against minors), regardless of their financial situation, and to encourage the reporting of such crimes.
The ruling, the first of 2021 and drafted by the Court's newly appointed president Giancarlo Coraggio, follows a question raised in 2019 by the preliminary investigation judge at the Tivoli court regarding the constitutional legitimacy of the automatic admission to state-funded legal costs for victims of violence.
The response contained in the new ruling explains how automatic admission "does not appear either unreasonable or in breach of the principle of equal treatment, given the vulnerability of the victims as well as the need to ensure that such crimes are brought to light as fully as possible".
Free legal costs for victims of violence
All victims will therefore be able to access legal costs covered by state-funded legal aid, without being subject to decisions based on financial criteria or, still less, to the discretion of the judge.
We want to put in place a more effective system to support victims, facilitating their involvement in the emergence and ascertainment of crimes
Giancarlo Coraggio, president of the Italian Constitutional Court
"In our legal system, and especially in recent years, considerable space has been given to provisions and measures aimed at ensuring a more effective response to crimes against sexual freedom and self-determination, which are regarded as a growing cause of social alarm, also in light of greater cultural and legal sensitivity on the issue of violence against women and minors," the ruling states.
Those who will be able to access legal coverage are, precisely, all victims of violent crimes. Although – sadly – the term is often associated with violence against women, the offences cited in the ruling include:
Ill-treatment of family members or cohabitants (article 572 of the penal code)
Practices of female genital mutilation (article 583-bis of the penal code)
Sexual violence (article 609-bis of the penal code)
Sexual acts with a minor (article 609-quater of the penal code)
Group sexual violence (article 609-octies of the penal code)
Stalking (article 612-bis of the penal code)
Child prostitution (article 600-bis of the penal code)
Child pornography (article 600-ter of the penal code)
Tourist initiatives aimed at the exploitation of child prostitution (article 600-quinquies of the penal code)
Trafficking in persons (article 601 of the penal code)
Corruption of a minor (article 609-quinquies of the penal code)
Although the ruling aims to combat the silence and impunity that are all too often associated with incidents of violence, and represents a step forward in the protection of victims, the efforts are not yet sufficient to counter – and therefore prevent – the problem at its root, which lies in the culture of violence.
Italy guarantees free legal assistance to all victims of violence
Rights — di Camilla Soldati
In a landmark ruling, the Constitutional Court has established that all victims of violence may access free legal assistance, through state-funded legal aid.