Fake rhino horns to combat poaching

Fake rhino horns to combat poaching

Environment · ·

Scientists are planning to flood the black market with realistic replicas in an attempt to reduce poaching.

Rhinos are being killed at an unsustainable rate and, according to the organisation Save the Rhino, they could become extinct in the wild in fewer than 30 years. In 2018, in South Africa alone, 769 rhinos were killed by poachers. These enormous herbivores are the victims of relentless hunting on account of their horn, which has reached exorbitant prices.

Read also: From GPS to dehorning. All the ideas to save rhinos

To prevent the dramatic disappearance of these ancient and charismatic creatures, scientists have so far tried various solutions. From fitting GPS devices in the animals' horns, to relocating them to safer areas (even on another continent), to deploying actual bodyguards, to dehorning. To these could soon be added a new and original strategy, currently under consideration by scientists, which involves flooding the black market with realistic replicas of rhino horns.

Primo piano di un esemplare di rinoceronte nero
Rhino horn is used primarily in traditional Asian medicine, where it is believed to combat impotence and to possess numerous healing properties. Every beneficial power attributed to it is, however, entirely without scientific foundation © Ingimage

Horns made from horsehair

The idea, set out in the study Creating artificial rhino horns from horse hair, comes from three researchers at the Department of Zoology at the University of Oxford and China's Fudan University. The scientists have found a way to produce faithful replicas of rhino horns using horsehair.

Read also

Flooding the market

The aim would be to saturate the market with fakes in order to reduce the value of horns and counter poaching. "Economists think that by flooding the market with fake horns, the price will drop," explained co-author of the research Fritz Vollrath. If the price falls and the penalties linked to the illegal trade in horns remain high, trafficking could cease to be so profitable, thereby discouraging poaching.

How to create a fake horn

Rhino horns are made of keratin, like nails and hair. To replicate them, the researchers glued together hairs from a horse's tail — an animal related to rhinos — using a silk-based substance. The resulting material can be easily moulded into the shape of a rhino horn, then dried and polished. The result is an object that is surprisingly similar to the original and difficult to distinguish even under a microscope. "From our investigation it appears that it is quite easy, as well as cheap, to make a material that mimics the outrageously expensive nose hair tuft of the rhino," the study's authors wrote.

Corni di rinoceronte tagliati in un allevamento in Sudafrica
Scientists believe that putting a large quantity of fake horns on the market could sow confusion and cause a collapse in prices, making poaching less profitable © Leon Neal/Getty Images

Save the Rhino's objection

Not everyone, however, considers it a good idea. Save the Rhino, a UK-based NGO dedicated to the conservation of these large mammals, has warned that this strategy could inadvertently stimulate the market for rhino horns. The organisation believes it would be more important to focus on adopting anti-poaching measures and on efforts to reduce consumer demand.