COP29 in Baku opens with an agreement on the global carbon credits market
Environment — di Valentina Neri
The opening day of COP29 marks a step forward on the international carbon credits market. But without any real debate.

The opening day of COP29 marks a step forward on the international carbon credits market. But without any real debate.
It was an uphill start for COP29, the twenty-ninth Conference of the Parties on climate, being held in Baku, Azerbaijan, from 11 to 22 November 2024. Despite walkouts and delays, however, this year too – as in 2023 – a result was achieved on the very first day of negotiations. At COP28 in Dubai it had been the turn of the loss and damage fund; this year the protagonist is Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, which governs the global carbon credits market.
The first day of negotiations in Baku focused on Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, whose objective is to encourage collaboration between states on emissions reductions. The mechanism is that of carbon credits, the so-called "rights to pollute": in simple terms, a state that stays below a given emissions threshold earns credits that it can transfer to another state which has instead generated more greenhouse gases than permitted. In doing so, decarbonisation becomes economically advantageous.
Given that every country is required to submit its own emissions reduction plans (nationally determined contributions, NDCs), Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement enables them to reach agreements with one another to exchange these mitigation outcomes. Technically, these are known as ITMOs, internationally transferred mitigation outcomes. The mechanism works roughly as follows: state A buys a credit from state B, and the latter spends the money received on a project with a positive impact (such as installing solar panels or electrifying public transport). State A can then account for the saved emissions within its own NDCs, just as it would for a project carried out at home. Alternatively, it can sell them to another state that needs them. The important thing is not to count them twice (in jargon, this is known as double counting). Around ninety agreements of this kind have been signed so far, but the only one to have reached completion is that between Switzerland and Thailand.
So far, this concerns only bilateral agreements between states. Article 6.4 of the Paris Agreement instead provides for the establishment of a new international carbon credits market, overseen by the United Nations, in which both public and private actors can participate.
After years of deadlock, the opening day of COP29 marked an important step forward on the international carbon credits market. "By efficiently bringing together buyers and sellers, this market could reduce the cost of implementing NDCs by 250 billion dollars a year," declared COP29 president Mukhtar Barbayev. In this context, the buyers are industrialised countries, which are significantly behind in their decarbonisation journey, and the sellers are developing countries that need resources to protect their CO2 reservoirs (such as forests) or to develop clean energy projects.
The two new standards for the carbon credits market concern respectively the removal of CO2 and the development and assessment of projects. The first topic, in particular, appears rather contentious. "The text leaves many questions unanswered, for instance on how to manage projects whose benefits risk being reversed: for example, storing CO2 in a natural reservoir that could release it after a few years," explains Isa Mulder, who is attending COP29 in Baku on behalf of Carbon Markets Watch. And while representatives of indigenous peoples fear the "sell-off" of their lands for tree planting, there are also those who worry that experimental technologies of still uncertain yield may end up in the CO2 offsetting mix.
None of this, however, was discussed. The procedure was in fact rather irregular, because the two new standards for the carbon credits market had in reality already been finalised. They had been prepared in recent weeks by the technical experts of the supervisory body for the Article 6.4 mechanism, without proposing – as is usually done – several alternative versions to choose from. This sped up the process but, in practice, drastically limited the space for debate. According to Erika Lennon, a lawyer at the Center for International Environment Law, this represents "a dangerous precedent for the entire negotiating process."