Cop28, how the CO2 offset market threatens indigenous peoples
Environment — di Maurizio Bongioanni
Day 6 of Cop28 focused on indigenous rights. But some are speaking out: the CO2 credit market is a threat to their land.

Day 6 of Cop28 focused on indigenous rights. But some are speaking out: the CO2 credit market is a threat to their land.
The world is watching Cop28 in the knowledge that the fate of our planet is at stake. Attention is now focused not only on mitigation strategies and financial agreements, but also on the integration of human rights into negotiating texts. On 5 December, Cop28 held discussions on indigenous peoples' rights, but NGOs are concerned that the Dubai negotiations risk paving the way for the CO2 credit offset market (carbon credits) among emissions reduction measures.

Thousands of companies are already turning to the offset market to meet their carbon neutrality targets, yet several studies — one of the most comprehensive being that carried out by the British organisation Carbon Brief — have shown that the effects on emissions reductions are rather negligible: it is estimated that only 12 per cent of offsets sold translate into real emissions reductions.
But the carbon credits market is also controversial and lacking in transparency, especially when indigenous peoples are involved — those who live in the territories subject to offsetting — to the point of becoming "as great a threat to indigenous lands as logging and mining", as NGO Survival International declared ahead of Cop28. "Governments, big business and conservation NGOs will work together to promote the CO2 credit market instead of seriously addressing the real causes of the climate crisis."
Survival sees this offsetting instrument as a "new, powerful tool for profiting from the theft of indigenous lands". Some time ago, the NGO exposed the serious shortcomings of a model CO2 credit programme managed by the Northern Rangeland Trust in Kenya, a project used by Meta and Netflix to offset their emissions. Not only had this project allegedly never received the 'free, prior and informed consent' of the indigenous inhabitants of those lands, "it does not even store additional CO2".
In short, major conservation NGOs are waiting in the wings to extract millions of dollars from indigenous lands that were previously stolen and turned into protected areas, and the boom in this market — "lacking adequate safeguards, is accelerating the creation of new protected areas and other offsetting projects on lands taken from indigenous peoples," Survival argues. In fact, it is not only the NGO dedicated to defending indigenous rights that has taken this position: many movements accuse industrialised countries of "neocolonialism", as large swathes of land in the "global south" are effectively being "locked up" with the aim of absorbing CO2 produced in the north. Indeed, in 70 per cent of the reports examined by Carbon Brief, evidence of harm to indigenous populations — such as those in Peru, Kenya and Zimbabwe — was found.
Furthermore, the certification bodies for these credits have been criticised in several journalistic investigations: the two most important certification bodies in the world, whose role is to guarantee what an offsetting project is "worth" in terms of emissions, are the Swiss company South Pole and the American company Verra. South Pole is accused by the journalistic platform Follow the Money of having certified projects for British Petroleum (Bp) and Spotify whose credits originate from cotton fields in China's Xinjiang region, where the risks of forced labour are particularly high.
Verra, meanwhile, was the subject of a thorough investigation by the weekly Die Zeit, whose journalists reported that as many as 94 per cent of the offset credits guaranteed by the company are in fact "phantom credits" — that is, without any effect on the climate. In addition, Verra is accused of sexual harassment towards women from indigenous communities in Zimbabwe, as recently documented by NGO Somo.
For the occasion, three NGOs — Survival International, Amnesty International and Minority Rights Group International — signed a letter denouncing the illegal evictions of the Ogiek indigenous people of Kenya, highlighting the role that conservation projects and CO2 credits can play in what are described as outright "land grabs".
In particular, the NGOs are calling on the Kenyan government to halt all evictions in the Mau Forest, as they violate Kenyan law as well as the rulings of the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights regarding the Ogiek. More than 167 homes have been destroyed (including a school), leaving 700 people, including children and people with disabilities, without a home.
The Ogiek, refusing to leave their land, are now living in the open, exposed to the elements. The organisations explain that Kenya has recently signed agreements that will pave the way for reforestation and also for the issuance of CO2 credits over millions of hectares of land. Projects such as this demonstrate that moves aimed at expanding the credit market in the Global South could enormously increase the theft of indigenous lands, increase financial support for violent projects in the name of "conservation" and in all likelihood cause further waves of evictions.

But let us return to the work of the Cop: the Paris Agreement of 2015 had already provided for the establishment of a global market for CO2 emissions offsetting. Ahead of the ongoing Cop28 in Dubai, the Cop's supervisory body has been working on concrete proposals for how to regulate this market, under the auspices of the United Nations but without having consulted representatives of the indigenous peoples affected by this mechanism.
Indeed, few indigenous voices have spoken out during Cop28: one of them is that of María José Andrade Cerda, from the Kichwa community of Serena, in Ecuador. "Today I am also the voice of my grandmother, who taught me the wisdom of our culture and of Mother Nature. She taught me that the troubled flight of the suyu pishkus means that torrential rains are approaching. These birds give us weather signals and we interpret them as premonitory signs that allow us to adapt to climate change."
"Cop28 represents a critical juncture in the journey of the climate crisis: here it will be decided whether to achieve real reductions in CO2 emissions or to continue peddling false solutions," writes Survival. "The recent agreements that Blue carbon, a company linked to the royal family of the United Arab Emirates, which has struck deals with various African countries, demonstrates how great the impact of false solutions is on indigenous peoples. Blue carbon has secured an area of land the size of the United Kingdom for offset projects, and recently the Kenyan government signed an agreement in which millions of hectares of its territory are requisitioned for the production of CO2 credits."