A Swiss study has found a direct correlation between agricultural expansion at the expense of forests and levels of inequality within communities.
The haemorrhage of tropical forests leaving the planet increasingly bare, stripped of its irreplaceable green lungs, shows no sign of stopping. Tree felling in the Amazon continues at a reckless pace and deforestation, after a brief dip, has started rising again. In 2018 alone, we lost 4,859 square kilometres of the world's largest rainforest, further accelerating climate change. One effective way to counter deforestation, at least in Latin America, would be to reduce social inequality.
Commercial agriculture is one of the main causes of deforestation in Latin America and, according to the FAO, was responsible for around 70 per cent of forest clearance between 2000 and 2010. According to the study's author, improving agricultural productivity, which could slow its expansion, is not sufficient on its own to prevent agricultural expansion and deforestation; action must also be taken at a political and institutional level. "We know that different forms of inequality can have a significant impact on the formulation of environmental laws," said Ceddia. "More work needs to be done to eliminate inequalities. It is surprising how little we focus on this social disease."
Countries characterised by high rates of social inequity, as previous research has shown, are typically marked by weak institutions, which are less likely to enforce regulations, including controls on agricultural expansion and forest protection. Ceddia's research, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, is the first to highlight significant links between agricultural productivity in Latin America and different forms of inequality.
The study examines data from ten Latin American countries (Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Guyana, Mexico, Peru, Suriname and Venezuela) over a twenty-year period (from 1990 to 2010) and three different forms of inequality: income, land and wealth. The findings suggest that, in a hypothetical situation of equality, an increase in agricultural productivity would boost deforestation in the short term. When this ideal scenario is assessed over the long term, however, it emerges that greater agricultural productivity would in fact lead to better forest protection. What is certain is that rising levels of inequality of all kinds promote agricultural expansion at the environment's expense in every case. Social disparities, according to the author, could hinder the social cooperation needed to protect forests, or agricultural expansion could accelerate when land ownership is concentrated in a few hands.
According to the ranking of the world's most unequal nations, published in 2016 by the World Bank, Latin America is one of the most unjust regions on the planet. Of the 14 countries featured in the ranking, no fewer than six are Latin American. "If we want to ensure that increased agricultural productivity serves to protect tropical forests, the message to policymakers is clear," explained Graziano Ceddia. "A more equitable distribution of income, wealth and land ownership is needed."
The best way to tackle deforestation, at least in Latin America, is to reduce inequality
Environment — di Lorenzo Brenna
A Swiss study has found a direct correlation between agricultural expansion at the expense of forests and levels of inequality within communities.