How climate change is reshaping the geography of crops

How climate change is reshaping the geography of crops

Food · ·

Maize, rice, coffee, cacao and wine: which crops are most at risk from climate change around the world and in Italy.

A double thread ties agriculture to climate change. On the one hand, food systems are responsible for one third of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions that cause global warming: the majority of these stem from the use of land for agriculture (particularly for crops and livestock) and from changes in land use.

coltivazioni
Agriculture is both responsible for and a victim of climate change © iStock

On the other hand, agriculture, given its deep dependence on natural resources and climatic conditions, suffers the effects of climate change: violent rainfall, flooding, increasingly frequent and prolonged periods of drought, wildfires, the growing proliferation of pests and diseases, and rising sea levels damage production and compromise harvests.

Climate change penalises agriculture in low-latitude countries

The geography of crops is set to change, and this will have effects on food security and migration, above all in countries where the survival of populations and the economy depend on a small number of products. According to the Ipcc, agriculture will be consistently and negatively affected by climate change in low-latitude countries and, although some high-latitude regions may instead benefit from climate change, soil quality and water availability could limit this advantage. Harvests are expected to decline as temperatures rise, especially in tropical and semi-tropical regions, and aridity is projected to increase in parts of central and eastern South Asia and West Africa. The Mediterranean region will also continue to experience a reduction in productivity.

The effects of natural disasters on agricultural production, as quantified economically (and nutritionally) by the Fao

Recently, the Fao published the first global estimate of the effects of natural disasters on agricultural production — disasters that have increased from 100 to 400 per year from the 1970s to the last two decades. According to the report, over the past thirty years agricultural and livestock production has suffered losses estimated at 3.8 trillion dollars due to calamitous events, a figure equivalent to 5 per cent of global agricultural GDP. The report covers crops and livestock, but the figures could be considerably higher if systematic data on the sub-sectors of fisheries, aquaculture and forestry were available.

coltivazioni
The loss of nutrients and energy from food per person per day from 1991 to 2021 linked to the effects of climate on agriculture © Fao

In particular, the figures reveal that over the past thirty years cereals recorded an average loss of 69 million tonnes per year — equivalent to France's entire cereal production in 2021 — followed by fruit, vegetables and sugar, with average losses of around 40 million tonnes per year. For fruit and vegetable products, the losses correspond to the entire 2021 production of Japan and Vietnam. Disasters inflicted the greatest collateral losses on lower-middle-income countries, up to 15 per cent of their total agricultural GDP. On a global scale, estimated losses due to disasters in the crop and livestock sub-sectors averaged approximately 147 kcal per capita per day over the past 31 years, a figure corresponding to around 6–7 per cent of the average energy requirement of men and women.

Which crops around the world are at risk from climate change

Maize and wheat

According to a Nasa study published in the journal Nature Food, climate change could affect the production of maize and wheat as early as 2030 in a high greenhouse gas emissions scenario. Maize harvests are projected to fall by 24 per cent, especially in the tropics, while wheat could potentially see growth of around 17 per cent as it expands to higher latitudes. It should be noted that, while a modest increase in atmospheric CO2 concentration could on the one hand improve crop productivity, on the other it reduces the nutritional quality of certain foods: for example, wheat grown at atmospheric CO2 concentrations approximately 32–42 per cent higher than current levels may contain 5.9–12.7 per cent less protein, 3.7–6.5 per cent less zinc and 5.2–7.5 per cent less iron.

coltivazioni
Maize production could collapse by 20 per cent as early as 2030 © iStock

Rice

Rice cultivation is threatened by flooding, drought, rising sea levels and increasing temperatures. According to a study, in the future in China, the world's largest rice producer, the rice growing period will shorten and yields will decline. In the summer of 2023, India, the world's second-largest rice producer, halted exports of the grain because production had been compromised — in some areas by excessive rainfall, in others by scarce precipitation. In Vietnam, rice paddies have long been being converted into shrimp farms.

Coffee and cacao

According to Ipcc estimates, by 2050 land dedicated to coffee production will decrease worldwide. In Brazil, the world's largest coffee producer, a temperature increase of 3°C would reduce by two thirds the area suitable for coffee production in the main growing states of Minas Gerais and São Paulo, and would make it entirely impossible in others. Climate change will also have a significant impact by 2050 on cacao production in West Africa, where Ghana and Ivory Coast currently produce more than half of the world's cacao.

coltivazioni
By 2050, land dedicated to coffee production will decrease worldwide © iStock

Wine

According to data from the Oiv, the 2023 wine vintage, with 244.1 million hectolitres produced worldwide, is the poorest in the past sixty years (-7 per cent on 2022). A downward trend in wine has been under way for some time due to climate change, with floods, frosts and drought compromising grape production. Italy, among the worst-affected countries, lost its status as Europe's leading wine producer in 2023; output also fell for major producers in the southern hemisphere: Chile, Australia, South Africa, Argentina.

Climate change and at-risk crops in Italy

According to Coldiretti estimates, in 2023 agricultural damage in Italy linked to extreme weather events exceeded six billion euros. In particular, a cut of 10 per cent was recorded in wheat production, of 14 per cent in wine grape production and of up to 63 per cent in pears, while the honey harvest fell by 70 per cent compared to 2022. As for rice (Italy produces 50 per cent of Europe's supply), 2023 recorded the lowest output in the past twenty years.