Ranking: how countries use their natural resources

Ranking: how countries use their natural resources

Environment · ·

80% of exporting countries manage their mineral and oil resources poorly. A shame. More than a billion people could live better.

A new ranking joins the reports that allow us a clearer understanding of how the world is tackling the ecological crisis: it comes from the Revenue Watch Institute in New York, which will from now on release the Resource Governance Index every year.

The vast majority of countries manage their mineral and oil resources poorly
More than 80% of the world's largest exporters of oil, gas and minerals fail to meet "acceptable standards" in the management of their natural resources. The report uses all the economic and geopolitical indicators needed to map political, environmental, social, inefficiency and corruption problems.
58 countries were analysed against parameters of transparency and accountability of revenues from industrial activities in the sectors indicated. The index was also created to give wealthy countries an additional tool to avoid feeding the "resource curse" — the phenomenon whereby many poor economies, despite being rich in precious materials, not only fail to benefit from them but are also depleted ecologically and in terms of labour by those who exploit their resources. Weak institutional oversight is a contributing cause of the slow growth of many emerging economies. "The lives of more than a billion people could be transformed if only their governments learned to manage their resources properly, in an open and transparent way," says Revenue Watch, presenting the Resource Governance Index.

Resource Governance Index: the poor countries
The resource governance index ranks countries on a scale of 1 to 100. Norway is in first place with a governance score of 98, followed by the United States with 92. Myanmar has the lowest score, 4, just a whisker ahead of Turkmenistan.
Countries are assessed across four areas: legal framework, levels of transparency, government oversight of activities on their territory, and management capacity. Only 11 of the 58 exporting countries are above the "acceptable" level of 70. According to Revenue Watch, "More than half of the sample, 32 countries, does not even reach basic standards in the governance of its resources, exercising poor oversight or none at all." The worst-performing countries are, moreover, those that base their economies almost entirely on profits from extractive or oil activities. The index cites, for example, Nigeria, whose oil revenues alone exceed total aid granted to sub-Saharan Africa in 2011 by 60 per cent; Libya, which, despite being Africa's second-largest oil producer, is drawing down the monetary reserves of its central bank; and Equatorial Guinea, which statistically has a per capita income higher than England's yet three quarters of its population lives below the poverty line. Revenue Watch also highlights the cases of Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan, placed very low in the ranking, in 48th and 49th place respectively.

Resource Governance Index: the wealthy countries
But even the countries ranked highly do not escape criticism: "Canada, the US and Australia should require their mining and energy companies not to take advantage of the opacity of the many countries in which they operate — notes Daniel Kaufmann, president of Revenue Watch — but advances must also be made in their domestic markets." Kaufmann draws attention to the American Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, which required companies with public concessions to publicly declare how much they pay the state for those concessions, but some trade organisations are appealing to federal and local courts to avoid doing so. A change for the worse in the rules — a negative example that, through the policies of multinationals headquartered in the US, could spread throughout the world.