Caporalato. 30,000 farmworkers regularised: the amnesty is only a partial success

Caporalato. 30,000 farmworkers regularised: the amnesty is only a partial success

Rights · ·

The amnesty for foreign workers launched by Agriculture Minister Bellanova attracted 207,000 applications, but only 15 per cent concern farmworkers.

The Ministry of the Interior received more than 207,000 applications for the regularisation of undeclared employment relationships, which the government had made possible through the Rilancio decree passed last May, in the midst of the coronavirus emergency.

Conclusa la procedura per #emersione dei rapporti di #lavoro: presentate più di 207mila domande.
13mila quelle per il rilascio di #permessodisoggiorno temporaneo. On line il report statistico.

#17Agosto
@MinLavoro
@poliziadistato

📰➡️interno.gov.it/it/node/21206

The amnesty was intended by the government above all to salvage the harvest season, by guaranteeing greater protections for agricultural farmworkers — almost all foreign nationals, and largely undocumented — and had even been greeted with emotion by Agriculture Minister Teresa Bellanova, who, in tears at the Palazzo Chigi press conference, had said that "from today the invisible will be a little less invisible, from today we can say that the State is stronger than caporalato".

Things did not quite go that way, or at least the amnesty produced less significant results than had been anticipated. While it is true that the government estimated the potential pool of beneficiaries at up to 600,000 undocumented individuals, receiving applications for a third of them might in itself be considered a satisfactory outcome. The problem, if anything, is that 85 per cent of applications (177,000), according to data from the Ministry of the Interior, concerned the regularisation of domestic workers and carers, and only the remaining 15 per cent concerned dependent employees — that is, the agricultural farmworkers who were the true heart of the measure: 30,000 farmworkers, one in every five of the 150,000 estimated to be present on Italian territory.

Why so few farmworkers regularised?

Many of the reasons behind the more muted response than expected were probably inherent in the eligibility requirements set out by the law itself: the measure applied, for instance, exclusively to those who had already obtained a regular employment contract in 2019, effectively excluding all those who for years had been providing seasonal undeclared labour — in other words, the vast majority of migrants. Furthermore, any employer wishing to regularise a worker faced the disincentive of having to pay a one-off tax of 500 euros, roughly equivalent to that worker's monthly undeclared wage. Not to mention that the regularisation provided for was effectively temporary — only for six months: only if, at the end of that period, the foreign national was still in possession of a dependent employment contract would the permit then be converted into a residence permit for work purposes.

Caporalato. 30mila braccianti in regola: la sanatoria è un successo a metà
The great majority of Italian agricultural businesses, according to the Cia, have freed themselves from caporalato, but there are still 150,000 undeclared workers in the sector © GettyImages

Minister satisfied, civil society less so

Minister Bellanova nevertheless expressed satisfaction, speaking of "significant numbers that once again confirm the soundness of the measure, its necessity, the rightness of the path undertaken, which must now necessarily continue with the three-year plan against caporalato, with the platform that facilitates transparent matching of labour supply and demand. Our objective is clear: to free people and workers from undeclared labour and caporalato, which is not confined to agriculture." Since 2016, Italy has indeed had a law against caporalato, which aims to support virtuous agricultural businesses, but which has yet to fully deliver on its effects, according to industry associations.

Oltre duecentomila persone, uomini e donne, sottratte all’invisibilità e restituite alla dignità e regolarità dei…

Pubblicato da Teresa Bellanova su Lunedì 17 agosto 2020

But according to the volunteer association Baobab Experience, which for five years has been working on reception, legal protection and employment integration for migrants, the Ministry of the Interior's data comes as no surprise. "What could we have expected from a regularisation that required a slave master, suddenly repentant, to bend to the law and voluntarily choose to pay a 500-euro tax (more than he has ever given in a month to any farmworker), to provide decent pay, humane hours and pay the required social security contributions? Or perhaps that the farmworker, forced into undeclared work, with no contract or a fictitious contract, would be able to prove that he had spent hours and days under the blazing sun harvesting our made in italy?"

Molto rumore per nullaMaggioranza di governo spaccata, opposizioni in preda a deliri rabbiosi, estenuanti giornate di…

Pubblicato da Baobab Experience su Giovedì 20 agosto 2020

Data by region and country of origin

Lombardy is the region from which the highest number of applications for domestic and personal care work were submitted (47,357), while Campania leads for dependent employment (6,962). At provincial level, the top three are Milan (22,122), Naples (19,239) and Rome (17,318) for applications relating to undeclared domestic work, and Caserta (2,904), Ragusa (2,005) and Latina (1,897) for undeclared dependent employment. As regards the country of origin of the workers, finally, Ukraine, Bangladesh and Pakistan come top for domestic and personal care work, while Albania, Morocco and India lead for dependent employment.