Canada bows to the oil industry and nationalises the Trans Mountain pipeline

Canada bows to the oil industry and nationalises the Trans Mountain pipeline

Energy · ·

Canada seemed destined to lead the energy transition towards renewables, yet, in a surprise move, the Trudeau government purchased Trans Mountain at a cost of 2.9 billion euros.

A surprise move, but not a pleasant one, from Canada. The Canadian government has purchased from the American company Kinder Morgan the Trans Mountain pipeline and the related expansion project for approximately 2.9 billion euros. The aim of the operation is to ensure that the infrastructure is actually built. A country that until now had appeared at the forefront of wanting to abandon fossil fuels and seemed to have embraced a series of reforms and measures in favour of the energy transition, has in recent days surprised with a singular move in favour of the oil industry that has caused considerable consternation.

Fossil fuels are subsidized 38x more than renewables globally. Now the Canadian government wants to spend billions more of taxpayer dollars to increase its country’s contribution to the climate crisis. This is not in the public interest. We must keep fighting to #StopKM.

A project for 890,000 barrels of oil per day

Trans Mountain is a pipeline strongly contested by environmentalists and local communities that runs between Alberta and Vancouver, and is crucial for introducing the oil sands petroleum of the province of Alberta onto international markets. Its capacity is around 300,000 barrels of oil per day, but with the expansion plan — which envisages 980 new kilometres at an estimated cost of approximately 7.4 billion dollars — it could reach 890,000 barrels per day. The pipeline connects the terminal in Edmonton, Alberta, to the maritime port of Vancouver, in British Columbia.

The project is viewed very favourably by the oil industry, which considers it a crucial connecting infrastructure for Asian markets, allowing producers to diversify their markets and reduce their excessive dependence on the American market, which is currently the main recipient of Canadian oil exports.

Today, we’ve taken action to create & protect jobs in Alberta and BC, and restart construction on the TMX pipeline expansion, a vital project in the national interest. Watch Ministers @Bill_Morneau and @jimcarr_wpg: bit.ly/2IX5bfw

Investing in oil-related infrastructure: a historic mistake for Canada, according to many

The project that Canada has decided to purchase, effectively nationalising the infrastructure, is at the centre of much controversy. Adam Scott, senior advisor at Oil Change International, said that "Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is making a historic mistake", adding that the government "is effectively doing 'whatever it takes' to undermine our transition to a safe, clean, renewable energy future." But Canadian Finance Minister Bill Morneau and Natural Resources Minister Jim Carr have no doubts: the pipeline "must be built and will be built," Morneau himself said. With the agreement just finalised, works that had previously been suspended will be able to resume as early as this summer. And it is on this point that the government itself has insisted, also justifying the operation as a means of protecting the thousands of jobs in Alberta and British Columbia. The operation will be a key test for the Trudeau government, which will have to find a way to balance the environment and the economy "the old-fashioned way."

Oleodotto Trans Mountain
The Trans Mountain pipeline running between Alberta and Vancouver. © U.S. Geological Survey /Flickr

A plan to sell the newly purchased pipeline as soon as possible

The implementation of the government's plan involves several phases. During the summer, works will resume with the help of a federal loan, but by 22 July, the government and Kinder Morgan will commit to seeking a buyer or private investors to whom to sell the project. The whole matter, the government hopes, should be resolved before Canada completes the purchase agreement reached in these days, and therefore before August. If everything goes smoothly as planned, the government would proceed to indemnify the new owner against any unforeseen costs or further delays. Morneau himself, in a statement, stressed that it is not the Canadian government's intention to remain holding "this hot potato" for too long.

Who got the better deal?

According to the government, the purchase of the pipeline will not weigh on taxpayers' pockets, although the actual costs related to the pipeline expansion have not been disclosed. There also appear to be no doubts about the feasibility of quickly finding a new buyer: "Many investors have already expressed interest in the project, including indigenous groups, Canadian pension funds and others," the Canadian Finance Minister sought to reassure. Meanwhile, the Alberta government will create an emergency fund of 2 billion dollars to cover any "unforeseen circumstances" that may arise during the course of the project. In return, Alberta will receive a value commensurate with its contribution, through equity or profit participation. Is this a win for Canadians? "That is a great question," said Paul Bloom, president of Toronto-based Bloom Investment Counsel Inc., which owns approximately 300,000 shares of Kinder Morgan Canada. What is certain, he added, is that it was "a good day for Kinder Morgan shareholders, who got a great price for their assets. The government was under tremendous political pressure to sign the deal. Did they overpay? Perhaps."