The European Central Bank's economic support plan has, to date, predominantly benefited the large multinationals in the fossil fuel sector.
The oil industry, the automotive sector and motorway builders. It is the giants of the fossil fuel-based economy and of an unsustainable development model that have benefited most from the bond-purchasing programme for bonds issued by European companies, launched in June 2016 by the European Central Bank (ECB). This was revealed in a report published at the end of 2016 by the Belgian NGO Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO).
EU finance: an enemy of the climate
Poring over the list of beneficiaries of the Corporate Securities Purchasing Programme (CSPP) — a programme on which, by the end of November, €46 billion had already been spent, with a target of €125 billion by end of 2017 — it is reasonable to question the climate sensitivity of the Frankfurt bankers. Eleven transactions in favour of Shell, 16 benefiting Italy's Eni, 7 for France's Total, 6 for Spain's Repsol. All oil companies. Bond purchases also include carmakers such as Daimler and BMW, 15 transactions each, Renault and, paradoxically, Volkswagen — the German carmaker at the origin of the dieselgate scandal, for which the European Union opened infringement proceedings in December against seven of its member states. Not to mention the Estonian company Eesti Energia, a pioneer in the exploitation of tar sands in the US, the French companies Veolia and Suez, champions of water privatisation, or Italy's Enel, at the centre of controversy over its involvement in the construction of dams in South America. Looking at the transactions involving Italy, beyond the already-mentioned Eni and Enel, it emerges that more than half of the bond purchases conducted through our central bank concerned the gas sector.
Luxury, weapons or low-cost airlines: for the ECB, it's just business
"With our programme we are pursuing a monetary policy objective and this is what takes precedence for us," an anonymous source commented when approached on the matter by the British daily The Guardian. Perhaps this is why, in addition to the giants of fossil fuels, automotive and road infrastructure, the ECB has allowed itself to purchase bonds in sectors with a poor sustainability profile: luxury goods with LVMH, weapons with Thales, low-cost airlines such as Ryanair — condemned earlier in the year by the very European Court of Justice to repay €12 million for competition violations — and even gambling with Austria's Novomatic.
The opaque face of quantitative easing
The fact that only large groups feature among the beneficiaries of the ECB's operation should not in itself come as a surprise: issuing a bond is an extremely complex operation that is beyond the reach of small and medium-sized local businesses. This is why, for CEO, the CSPP has been nothing other than a form of subsidy to large European companies. An additional lever alongside the broader quantitative easing programme promoted by the ECB in 2015 through the purchase of government bonds to counter speculation and the provision of low-interest loans to national central banks. It is no coincidence that the markets welcomed it positively, as the Financial Times showed last July. If the objective, however, is to push the eurozone economy out of crisis, one must ask whether the direction in which the ECB is pushing it is compatible with the commitments made at COP21.
On the side of fossil fuels: the position of the European Central Bank
Economy & innovation — di Andrea Paracchini
The European Central Bank's economic support plan has, to date, predominantly benefited the large multinationals in the fossil fuel sector.