Cars and the ecological transition, Federmanager's warning: 60,000 jobs at risk

Cars and the ecological transition, Federmanager's warning: 60,000 jobs at risk

Mobility · ·

Cars and the ecological transition, Federmanager's warning: 60,000 jobs at risk. As the EU postpones its decision on the ban on cars more

In the journey towards the ecological transition of cars, Brussels has taken a sharp U-turn. The adoption of the regulation providing for the definitive ban on the production of vehicles powered by internal combustion engines from 2035 onwards has, for the time being, been postponed to a date yet to be determined. Germany's uncertainty over this radical shift towards electrification has been joined by the strongly opposed positions of Poland, Bulgaria and the Italian government as well. While sharing the European decarbonisation goals, Palazzo Chigi maintains that these measures must be implemented by pursuing "an economically sustainable and socially equitable transition, planned and guided with great care, to avoid negative repercussions for the country both in terms of employment and production".

parlamento europeo
The European Parliament in Brussels © European Parliament from EU/Wikimedia Commons

Ban on petrol and diesel cars, Italian industry among the worst affected

The same conclusions had been reached, a few days earlier, by a study carried out by Federmanager and the Associazione italiana economisti dell'energia (Aiee). Too sharp a turn towards the electric car risks not being absorbed by our automotive supply chain, which is characterised mainly by small-sized companies. The components sector in particular — the heart of the Italian car industry — would be the most exposed, also owing to company size: out of 2,200 businesses, which employ 161,000 workers and generate 45 billion in turnover, as many as 500 would be severely at risk.

This is because the electric car entails a lower level of investment, estimated by the report at minus 25 per cent over 10 years, due to the reduced number of components required (around one sixth of those used by the conventional car) and the longer service life of electric vehicle production machinery. This is a scenario, explains Federmanager president Stefano Cuzzilla, that makes Italy "the most penalised country among the European component-producing nations in terms of job losses, with a minus 37 per cent of the workforce, that is to say approximately 60,000 jobs lost by 2040", which makes it imperative to "stem the haemorrhage of jobs and implement personnel retraining plans".

Auto elettriche fabbrica
An electric car plant in Germany © Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Italian companies lack managerial capacity

Italian companies in the sector, moreover, are poorly managed: only 39 per cent of companies in the sector have management capable of handling the transition. The report reveals that the use of external managers outside the ownership is common in 78 per cent of cases when it comes to foreign groups operating in Italy, while it drops to 30 per cent in the case of Italian groups (where a mixed management model predominates) and falls to just 6 per cent in the case of family-run businesses.

"Managers," Cuzzilla continues, "play a guiding role. Their presence is instrumental in steering the company towards innovation and sustainability targets, all the more so in this sector, which is exposed to competition from international players and is directly affected by the political choices of our neighbours, Germany above all, which accounts for 20 per cent of exports from the Italian automotive supply chain."

Auto e transizione ecologica, l'allarme di Federmanager: 60mila i posti di lavoro a rischio
The market share of electric cars is constantly rising ©Jens Schlueter/Getty Images

The proposal for a sector conversion fund

In the view of Federmanager and Aiee, electric vehicles do not represent the only path towards the ecological transition of the sector. For this reason, both organisations are looking to the Italian government for a framework of "clear rules, inspired by the principles of technological neutrality and gradualism in the transition, confirming the sustainability of future investments in the sector". In essence, there is no wish to abandon the decarbonisation goal, but "only with certain timescales and methods is it possible to bring about the change of model. Bureaucratic simplification and attraction of foreign investment must form part of this single strategy." Among Federmanager's proposals is the establishment of a sector conversion fund: this measure should be aimed above all at professional upskilling, following the example of what was achieved with the Fondo nuove competenze, also drawing on the resources of the Piano nazionale di ripresa e resilienza.