Pavel Durov's arrest reignites the debate on gender-based violence on Telegram

Pavel Durov's arrest reignites the debate on gender-based violence on Telegram

Economy & innovation · ·

Pavel Durov's arrest brings the relationship between Telegram and gender-based violence back into focus. We discuss it with Silvia Semenzin, a researcher specialising in online gender-based violence.

Pavel Durov, the founder of the messaging app Telegram, was arrested on Monday 26 August at Le Bourget airport in France, as part of an investigation into crimes related to child sexual abuse material, drug trafficking and fraudulent transactions on the platform. Paris prosecutor Laure Beccuau issued a statement setting out the reason for Durov's arrest, which took place in the context of an investigation against persons unknown launched by the office's cybercrime unit on 8 July.

The investigation concerns suspected complicity in a range of offences, including the management of an online platform enabling unlawful transactions, child sexual abuse material, drug trafficking and fraud, as well as refusal to communicate information to the authorities, money laundering and the provision of encryption services to criminals.

About the arrest of Pavel Durov, let's attention to the statement from Paris public prosecutor Laure Beccuau. It mentions an investigation, started on 8 july, against an unidentified person accused of 12 charges («This judicial investigation was opened against person unnamed, on

The arrest of the entrepreneur of Russian origin, who holds French and Emirati citizenship, immediately provoked a range of reactions; for many, it amounts to an attack on freedom of expression and a politically motivated act. French President Emmanuel Macron, seeking to calm the situation, published a statement on X denying the accusations and reaffirming France's role in safeguarding freedom of expression.

I have seen false information regarding France following the arrest of Pavel Durov.

France is deeply committed to freedom of expression and communication, to innovation, and to the spirit of entrepreneurship. It will remain so.

In a state governed by the rule of law,
37975 31325 26 ago 2024 · Apri su X →

Who is Pavel Durov

Durov was born in 1984 in Leningrad, now Saint Petersburg. His family moved to Italy when he was 4 years old, before returning to Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union, when his father received an offer to head a department at Saint Petersburg State University. According to Forbes, his fortune has been estimated at 15.5 billion dollars.

He has been nicknamed the "Russian Mark Zuckerberg" following the success of his social media platform VKontakte, or VK — the Russian answer to Facebook — founded in 2006, and the creation of the Telegram messaging app in 2013 together with his brother. In 2014 he was forced to leave Russia after he refused to shut down opposition accounts in 2011 and to hand over the personal data of pro-democracy Ukrainian protesters in 2014, during the Donbass war, and to block the profile of Alexey Navalny. He subsequently settled in Dubai for the ease of doing business, which he described in an interview as a geopolitically "neutral ground".

The Kremlin began blocking Telegram in 2018 after the company refused to comply with a Russian court order to grant state security services access to its users' encrypted messages. The move had little effect on Telegram's availability in the country, but sparked mass protests in Moscow and criticism from several NGOs.

Telegram's growing popularity, however, has drawn the attention of several European countries, including Spain and France, over security concerns and data breaches. In May, European regulators opened talks with the company to verify its compliance with the Digital Services Act (DSA), but just a few days ago Belgian authorities declared that the platform cannot be subject to European regulations because its user numbers have not yet exceeded 45 million monthly users. For this reason, Telegram can circumvent all the restrictions imposed by the European Union's digital regulatory package.

🇪🇸 Spain's High Court orders block on Telegram messaging app as a precautionary measure 👇
euronews.com/next/2024/03/2…

The right wing in defence of Durov

The international right was quick to come to Durov's defence, seizing on the case to its own advantage by accusing Paris of violating freedom of expression. Among the most prominent right-leaning business figures to speak out on the matter is Elon Musk, the owner of X, who on his social platform accused Europe of arresting people over memes and launched the hashtag #freepavel.

Musk is exploiting the case because in December the European Commission opened an investigation to verify X's compliance with the DSA, particularly regarding content moderation, the spread of fake news and terrorist material. In July, the first results of the investigation were released, confirming a breach of the regulations concerning the lack of transparency in the use of blue ticks.

POV: It’s 2030 in Europe and you’re being executed for liking a meme
283896 11458 24 ago 2024 · Apri su X →

Tucker Carlson, the journalist and former Fox News host who is close to former United States president Donald Trump and who had interviewed Durov in July, also tweeted attacking Europe, which he described as worse than Putin. Also noteworthy is the Russian position, which, through its national news agency, described Durov as the new Julian Assange.

Pavel Durov left Russia when the government tried to control his social media company, Telegram. But in the end, it wasn’t Putin who arrested him for allowing the public to exercise free speech. It was a western country, a Biden administration ally and enthusiastic NATO member,
140233 3625 24 ago 2024 · Apri su X →

Telegram and the black hole of gender-based violence

While Durov's messaging app is used by activists to share content that would otherwise be lost, there exists an enormous black hole in the form of Telegram groups in which every kind of gender-based violence is perpetrated. Since 2019, various investigations have been published into the exchanges — often violent and disturbing — that can be found in these groups.

Let me be clear: Freedom of speech does not include allowing dozens of public Telegram groups for image-based violence against women and girls.

I've reported over 50 such groups in the last two years and sent dozens of emails to @telegram!
#ViolenceAgainstWomen #ImageBasedAbuse

We discuss the link between Telegram and gender-based violence with Silvia Semenzin, a post-doctoral researcher in Digital Sociology at the Complutense University of Madrid and an expert in online gender-based violence.

Durov's arrest is the first genuine case in which a chief executive of a digital platform has been prosecuted. What do you make of it?
It is certainly a historic moment in terms of what it symbolises; personally, I take no pleasure in seeing a single individual punished in the face of a system that is not working. Having worked for years in the Telegram environment and knowing that it is perhaps the platform with the least regulation and the least oversight of all the unlawful phenomena circulating on it, I am watching how the situation unfolds with great attention.

We are talking about a multimillionaire entrepreneur who, over the years, has consistently refused to provide authorities with data relating to the unlawful content circulating on his platform. Durov, coming from the hacker world, has always hidden behind the issues of independence, privacy and freedom of expression in order to refuse to hand over data — even to combat certain phenomena — except in cases of terrorism and child sexual abuse material. When it comes to online scams, neo-fascist groups or gender-based violence, there has always been a wall. Even on the subject of encryption, it has emerged that Telegram is not as secure as the company has always claimed.

This arrest is certainly significant from a symbolic standpoint, particularly within the European Union, where a number of measures are being taken following the entry into force of the Digital Services Act and the Digital Markets Act, through which the Union is seeking to limit the power of Big Tech and these enormous platforms that, until now, have been something of a no man's land.

In recent years you have done a great deal of work on countering online gender-based violence, and Telegram is certainly one of the tools most widely used to commit this crime. Can it be the right vehicle for combating online gender-based violence, or is there a risk that Durov ends up paying on behalf of others?
With online gender-based violence we enter the hottest topic of all, which is that platforms are not neutral. They always emerge from a system, a political ideology, a worldview, and so there are certain areas in which they accept working with the authorities — such as terrorism — and there are phenomena in which they have absolutely no interest in collaborating, even to try to limit the violent acts that are, very often, suggested by the platform itself. Online gend