What needs to be done to clear the air in the Po Valley
Environment — di Rosy Battaglia
Sustainable mobility is the main solution to pollution in the Po Valley. But more concrete action is needed to support citizens.

Sustainable mobility is the main solution to pollution in the Po Valley. But more concrete action is needed to support citizens.
It was one of the regions in the world worst hit by Covid-19. It is the one with the greatest soil and inland water contamination in Italy. And where the worst air is breathed. The Po Valley remains the most polluted area in Europe, and that certainly does no good to the health of its inhabitants. Many factors make the situation so complex, starting with the excessive circulation of private and public vehicles with still heavily polluting emissions. Not to mention industry, intensive livestock farming, and heating systems. Together with the physical and meteorological factors that prevent atmospheric recirculation and the dispersal of particulate matter, as Paolo Corazzon, meteorologist at 3B Meteo, confirmed to us. All contributing causes that make the air in northern Italy extremely poor in quality, and that cost the community thousands of lost days of life and premature death for tens of thousands of people.
But what could the solutions be? While each of us can make a daily contribution by getting around on foot, by bike and by public transport as much as possible, systemic measures are needed that can be truly effective. In the meantime, it was precisely during the crisis caused by Covid-19 that proof emerged that one of the main factors on which action must be taken to rapidly clear the air in the Po basin is mobility. Confirmation comes from the European study Life Prepair, which processed data collected by environmental agencies during the first lockdown. The data revealed, for the first time, a 40 per cent collapse in nitrogen dioxide (NO2) emissions, thanks precisely to the near-total halt to transport in northern Italy.

Rebuilding from a foundation of zero-emission mobility in the provincial capitals of the Po Valley should therefore be a national priority. That is the view of Legambiente, which included it among the 10 flagship projects proposed to the Draghi government at the time of drafting the Piano nazionale di ripresa e resilienza (Pnrr). A measure that had been strongly advocated and supported by the previous Environment Minister, Sergio Costa. We should not forget that, in the absence of effective air quality policies requiring coordination between local, regional and national administrations, Italy now faces three infringement proceedings brought by the European Union — respectively for failing to comply with emission limits for PM2.5, PM10 and nitrogen dioxide. Evidence of this is also cited in the text of the Pnrr submitted to Brussels.
Despite this, Legambiente's request has gone unheeded by the current government, as Andrea Poggio, the association's head of sustainable mobility, confirms to LifeGate. "Unfortunately, the current recovery plan contains no concrete and immediate measures to bring air quality in the Po Valley and other polluted cities back within legal limits," the Legambiente official reiterates.
"Responsibility for this is shared between central government and the regions. The latter have been unable to draw up planning documents that meet Europe's requirements, which instead call for a drastic shift towards sustainable mobility." According to Andrea Poggio, "the measures presented by regional administrations during the drafting of the Pnrr, totalling two billion euros, were outdated. They provided for incentives to scrap and replace polluting vehicles with yet more petrol or diesel Euro 6 cars — vehicles that are already old, polluting and climate-altering according to European directives, and that in practice already exceed CO2 emission parameters today."
Meanwhile, in the very text of the Pnrr submitted to Brussels, we read that Italy makes a generic commitment to "implement a reform capable of adopting national air pollution control programmes," to "align national and regional legislation and introduce related accompanying measures to reduce emissions of atmospheric pollutants," (…) "in accordance with the objectives set by Directive 2016/2284 on national emission ceilings and climate-altering gases." In plain terms, this is an admission that, at present, a concrete national plan coordinated between central government and the regions is still lacking.
How all this will translate into practice is not yet known. What is certain, as the Pnrr text also states, is that one of the first steps will be the construction of charging points for electric vehicles and hydrogen refuelling stations. An initiative planned by the European Commission to meet emissions and pollution reduction targets by 2030. In Italy, it is estimated that to cover the energy demand required by electric mobility, more than 3.4 million charging infrastructures will be needed over the next decade.
But something is happening in the meantime, as Andrea Poggio points out. "On 10 November 2020, the European Court of Justice condemned Italy for ten years of 'systematic and persistent violation' of pollution rules across almost the entire Po Valley and in numerous other cities," he recalls. Action will therefore be needed, and it will likely be the prospect of European sanctions that forces central government and the regions to accelerate their political decisions.
"In recent months, Emilia-Romagna, Piedmont and Veneto have all passed resolutions introducing new 'extraordinary measures' against air pollution," Andrea Poggio points out. "This time, promises will not be enough, as the Veneto resolution itself makes clear: within two months, what is intended to be done must be communicated, and Europe will demand periodic checks. If pollution does not decrease, financial penalties are triggered immediately," warns the Legambiente official. In this case, however, it will not be a fine paid directly by central government, because "the Italian state will be able to seek redress from the parties responsible," including the "administrations responsible for the infringement." This information is set out in the Veneto regional resolution, which estimated it could face a fine of between 400 and 600 million euros."
What is needed, therefore, according to Legambiente, is greater courage and a vision for the future. "Certainly, the measure requested by the regions to provide financial support for replacing polluting cars is, in our view, justified. If on one hand the right air quality limits are set, on the other, states, central and regional governments must be given the powers and resources to renew the vehicle fleet, helping citizens through this change and promoting electric mobility in all its forms, from e-scooters to trains," Poggio explains.
"It is right that resources should be planned to reach zero emissions as quickly as possible. And we must start precisely from the Po Valley."
As our in-depth coverage has shown, smog — composed of particulate matter, nitrogen dioxide and other pollutants present in the atmosphere — enters our homes, potentially combining with the presence of unwanted VOCs. "Too often we ignore the fact that outdoor air quality is also dangerous for indoor air," Prof. Gianluigi De Gennaro, lecturer in environmental chemistry at the University of Bari and scientific director of the laboratory network "VOC and ODOR", which specialises in indoor pollution, reminds LifeGate. "The risk is that, since indoor spaces need to be aired frequently, in more polluted and traffic-heavy areas this practice can actually become counterproductive." All the more reason to take better and more thorough care of our atmosphere. Our health depends on it.