Saudi Arabia and the new frontiers of sportswashing

Saudi Arabia and the new frontiers of sportswashing

Rights · ·

The practice of authoritarian regimes using sport to gain power continues to expand. Sportswashing is spreading into new disciplines.

On 12 March 2022, Saudi Arabia announced that it had carried out 81 death sentences, executing men accused of being part of terrorist organisations, 41 of whom had been arrested for taking part in anti-government protests; just over ten days later, Formula 1 arrived with its multimillion-pound circus in the capital Jeddah to stage the Grand Prix. Without anyone making any reference to what had happened. Exactly one year later, Amnesty International reported that Saudi Arabia had sentenced to death at least twelve people accused of offences ranging from terrorism to drug trafficking, all without a fair trial. And all of it in the month of March alone. Less than a week later, Formula 1 returned for the second Grand Prix of the season, having previously been in Bahrain. And again, not a single official figure commented on the news.

sportwashing nella Formula 1
The Jeddah Corniche Circuit in Saudi Arabia © Dan Mullan/Getty Images

It was at this point that Yasser al-Khayyat, whose brother Mustafa was among the 81 people sentenced to death in 2022, decided to write a letter to Stefano Domenicali, former team principal of Ferrari and today president of Formula 1: "Silence is complicity. You are justifying heinous crimes by going racing in Saudi Arabia as if nothing has happened." In his letter, al-Khayyat levelled very serious accusations, pointing the finger at Formula 1 and accusing it of "sportswashing" on behalf of Saudi Arabia, which is trying to use sport to divert attention from the "thousand ways" in which it tramples on people's human rights and civil rights. Domenicali replied that Formula 1 wants to improve the situation, and that its work is proceeding differently, following other strategies. Without specifying, however, what those strategies are.

The new frontiers of sportswashing

Saudi Arabia's strategy is to exploit sporting events, and all the media attention that revolves around them, to project a different image of itself to the world, pushing every aspect of its domestic policy into the background. The Saudis do all this because they know that oil, their "black gold", is not infinite, and they therefore need to forge new alliances and new balances of power that will allow them to remain at the centre of global dynamics; in this light, sport represents a perfect connection, both for winning people over and for securing a prominent position. Initially they did so with less widely followed sports that nonetheless had a significant following, such as boxing or wrestling. Then they moved on to the world's most popular sport: football, which makes it possible to reach almost the entire planet. They began by inviting the various European leagues, always on the lookout for new investors, to play certain matches on their territory. For several years now, for example, the Spanish Liga has played its own Supercopa in Saudi Arabia and, in doing so, has decided to transform what was previously a one-off final into a four-team mini-tournament. Guaranteeing more matches logically makes it possible to obtain more money. The Spanish model has also appealed to our own Serie A, which a few weeks ago made official an agreement with the Saudis to do exactly the same thing as La Liga: the Italian Supercoppa will be played in Jeddah and in return Saudi Arabia will pay Serie A 23 million euros.

As far as football is concerned, the most complex operation is undoubtedly the acquisition of Newcastle, who play in the English Premier League. It is the richest league in the world, and having a team in that context means securing an international showcase that currently has no equal, not only in economic terms — probably the aspect that interests them least — but in terms of visibility and the opportunity to become embedded in the social fabric. Alongside the purchase of the club, the Public Investment Fund, a state investment fund of the country, has plans for several projects in the city of Newcastle, including shopping centres and all manner of hotels. The reason behind all of this is precisely to present themselves as a "beneficial" entity that puts money where there is none, making everything better. Newcastle, after years spent in the lower reaches of the English table, is now fighting for a place in the Champions League, and this makes the fans very happy; recently, at a national cup final, as well as waving their club's black-and-white flag, they were also waving the green flag of Saudi Arabia. Results of this kind allow the country to win the affections of entire sections of the population who see the Saudis as the ones who brought their club to glory. And not as the country that sentences to death those who try to demand greater freedom and rights.

sportwashing nel calcio
A Newcastle fan waving the Saudi Arabia flag © Daniel Chesterton/Offside/Offside via Getty Images

Sportswashing in golf

But if football is capable of reaching every section of the population, there are other disciplines that are far more élite. Golf is one example. It is a sport with a very specific audience, one that tends to be made up of the wealthier sections of the population. To "reach" them too, the same Saudi fund put together a very precise strategy: it decided to compete with the association that manages professional golf in the United States, the PGA Tour, which features the best players in the world. Saudi Arabia therefore set up a rival tour, calling it the LIV Tour, a name that plays on 54 written in Roman numerals (LIV), the number of holes in the tournament. The circuit began offering enormous fees to players who decided to switch.

PGA Tour suspends current and future LIV players.

The main weapon for attracting golfers is one and one alone: money. At each of the fourteen events on the schedule, 25 million dollars were up for grabs, four of which went to the winner. On top of this figure, a number of unspecified personal incentives were also offered to persuade players to leave the PGA and join the LIV Tour; this was also because the Americans, in an attempt to defend themselves against the new competition, had decided to automatically exclude from all their tournaments anyone who accepted the Saudis' offer. A threat that did not always produce the desired effect, both because the amount of money on offer is enormous even for a wealthy sport like golf, and because the PGA Tour itself does not exactly inspire widespread affection. American golfer Phil Mickelson, despite having described Saudi Arabia's handling of human rights as "horrible", said he had accepted because this was "a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity" to go up against the PGA Tour. The world's most famous golfer, Tiger Woods, on the other hand, pointed the finger at those who had switched tours, accusing them of ingratitude. The matter quickly ended up in court, where both sides accuse the other of unfair competition.

And then there's Trump…

In this work of "conquering" a new audience, and therefore new deals and power dynamics, Saudi Arabia has found a very important partner in Donald Trump. The former US president (and now candidate once again) collaborated with the PGA Tour for years, offering his golf courses as tournament venues, but after the assault on Capitol Hill on 6 January 2021 he was banned from the circuit, which decided to withdraw from the agreement. Trump thus followed the old saying that "the enemy of my enemy is my friend", embracing the cause of the LIV Tour and calling it "a wonderful organisation". Trump is still a very influential figure on the American scene: his supporters are mostly white men, in some cases very wealthy, broadly the same social class that follows golf. The fact that Trump therefore speaks about Saudi Arabia, albeit indirectly and through a sporting organisation, spreads a positive image of the country, which can then engage with certain circles in a different way, without excessive prejudice. Sport can become a fundamental means of telling one's story and presenting oneself in a new light, certainly more easily understood than other actions that rarely reach public opinion. Speaking to the upper echelons of the American population and offering them a sporting spectacle featuring the world's best golfers gives Saudi Arabia the opportunity to use the tournaments to try to forge new economic and diplomatic relationships.

Not only Saudi Arabia

Saudi Arabia is certainly not the first to put together such a strategy, and one need not look far to find other examples. Neighbours Qatar have long been setting the pace, above all in football: in 2011 they acquired Paris Saint-Germain, effectively revolutionising the dynamics of European football, and in December 2022 they managed to bring the most watched sporting event in the world, the football World Cup, to their small country. The Qatar edition was one of the most controversial ever, above all because of the working conditions of the many people who built the stadiums and more besides. Amnesty International submitted a letter, signed by over one million people from 190 different countries, to officially call on Fifa to compensate the migrant workers "who suffered horrible human rights violations in the organisation of the World Cup in Qatar", as the document reads.

During the 73rd #FIFACongress, FIFA President Gianni Infantino reflected on four years of record-breaking achievements for FIFA before outlining his objectives for the future following his re-election:

The 2030 World Cup is also Saudi Arabia's stated objective: to complete its sportswashing project, it aims, exactly as Qatar did, to host the tournament, so as to place itself ever more at the centre of world sport, with everything that can follow in terms of relationships, agreements and prestige. In this context, governed by power games and economic alliances, athletes can play a fundamental role. All too often, however, silence prevails and taking a stand is very rare. Returning to Formula 1, one of the few exceptions from this point of view is Lewis Hamilton, the seven-time world champion, who has stated that he feels uncomfortable racing in Saudi Arabia because he believes sport must do more to raise awareness of what is happening in the world and to help those fighting against authoritarian regimes. For as long as Hamilton and his views remain isolated cases, the sportswashing policy will be able to continue undisturbed.