What does it mean to be elderly and transgender? Is society ready to stand by them? We met some transgender women activists who told us their story. There is an invisible population: elderly transgender people.
"I didn't think I'd make it to 50. When I was a girl, being a transgender woman meant living on the streets. Prostitution was the only way to survive. No alternative. Violence, drugs, alcohol, AIDS, DIY hormone therapy: the dangers were so many that any long-term life expectancy was wiped out." The speaker is Antonia Monopoli, head of the Trans Ala Milano onlus helpdesk, which supports around 400 people each year who choose to begin the transition process.
In many cases, the possibility that transgender people might reach old age was probably never considered. Lives rendered fragile by serious risk factors, which until a few years ago were even heavier than they are today. In fact, there is now a section of the transsexual population that is approaching or already living through old age, often entirely in the shadows, just as it has lived its entire life.
Some countries, such as Australia, Spain and the United States, have already begun to address this issue through projects and academic research — including interdisciplinary work — aimed at studying and better mapping the socio-health conditions of adult transgender people, with the goal of highlighting their specific needs and requirements.
In Italy, only the very first steps are being taken, and a study by the Istituto superiore di sanità, conducted together with seven of the leading research centres for the clinical management of transgender people, has recently been launched.
The issue has therefore only just begun to be addressed, and the results of the research are not yet known. But what are the needs, the problems, the risk factors related to their health? How are they coping with old age? We met some transgender women activists who have passed the age of 50, in order to understand, on the one hand, how life has changed for people with gender dysphoria and, on the other, what they expect and what concerns they have about their future.
Stigma towards transgender people has changed little, and the defeat of the DDL Zan is undeniable proof of that
Nicole De Leo
How many transgender people are there in Italy
A first issue to address concerns the question of numbers, and our country is behind in statistics too. The Istituto superiore di sanità itself launched the first study in 2020 to find out how many transsexual people there are in Italy and to collect relevant data, particularly on the health problems affecting this section of the population.
The contacts behind the new institutional website InfoTrans tell us that "the data collected are being processed and will be published at the end of the study. Currently, analysis of the international literature suggests that the adult transgender population worldwide numbers between 0.5 and 1.2%; extrapolating these figures to the Italian population yields an estimate of around 500,000 transgender people." More than the entire population of the city of Bologna.
While awaiting the official research results, what appears clear is that requests for access to the Trans Ala helpdesk in Milan and the Movimento identità trans (Mit) in Bologna — two of the main points of reference for transsexuality in Italy — are rising sharply.
"We support around 2,000 people every year, and the numbers keep growing." So says Nicole De Leo, president of the Mit in Bologna and actress. "We receive almost a thousand calls a day from various Italian regions. We undoubtedly have more advanced media tools now and our reach has expanded. Stigma, on the other hand, has changed little — perhaps it is more veiled now, but it is still very much present, and the defeat of the ddl Zan is undeniable proof of that."
Parents used to disown their children; now they accompany them through the transition
"The Trans Ala Milan helpdesk intercepts requests for help from across northern Italy and takes on around 400 people per year, mostly young people. The waiting list for a first appointment can be as long as a month," explains Antonia Monopoli. "One strong early indicator of change is that many young people now come accompanied by their parents. Indeed, in many cases it is the parents themselves who contact us. A few years ago, this was unthinkable. For transsexual people of my generation, the norm was to be disowned by one's family. For many, the situation is still the same; rejection is still in force even decades on. It is worth noting that the concerns and questions that parents of transgender children put to us are identical to those of any parent: will they manage to have a peaceful life? Will they be able to find work and fulfil themselves? Will they be happy?"
Parents of transgender children ask us questions identical to those of any parent: will they manage to have a peaceful life? Will they be able to fulfil themselves? Will they be happy?
Antonia Monopoli
Female-to-male (F to M) transitions are on the rise
"Our clinic is the main vantage point for understanding how the trans dimension is evolving in today's society," adds Nicole De Leo. "A recent phenomenon, for example, is the considerable increase in requests for female-to-male (F to M) transitions, which have now surpassed those for male-to-female (M to F) transitions. I believe this trend goes hand in hand with the process of female self-determination. In other words, the fact that in recent years the female gender has undergone a very significant evolution has allowed many people to assert their identity more freely. Both internal and external conditions must be in place for certain steps to be taken."
As a woman, my temperament had always been gentle and kind. I think I still am, but it's hard for people to see beyond the patterns of traditional masculinity
Jude
The male-dominated society that more readily accepts female-to-male transitions
Pervasive male chauvinism is also reflected in the different levels of stigmatisation towards transgender people, depending on the gender they tend towards. "As a general rule, the female-to-male transition is more accepted, because the person is moving closer to the gender considered stronger," says Antonia Monopoli.
"On an aesthetic level, the 'F to M' transition is less visible and therefore easier to blend in with. I think, for example, of the workplace. For 'M to F' people it is exactly the opposite: the level of transphobia is higher because one is moving away from the stronger male gender towards the weaker one. Moreover, certain physical traits — such as voice, height and bone structure — often make 'M to F' transgender people more easily recognisable and, as a result, less easy to integrate and more stigmatised."
What future for elderly transgender people?
In Italy's increasingly long-lived population, where there are now five people over 65 for every child, addressing the issue of old age is an urgent and complex matter. The situation of transgender people, however, is so hidden, varied and subjective as to warrant a specific in-depth look.
According to a study conducted by the American Society of Gerontology and published by Oxford University Press, transsexual people report higher rates of victimisation, stigma and suicide attempts than non-transgender LGBT adults.
Also higher, again compared to the LGBT individuals surveyed, is the tendency of transgender adults to avoid healthcare, both out of fear of disclosing their gender identity and because of the perception — and direct experience — of healthcare providers' inability to offer adequate care for their needs. They also often have fewer financial resources, precisely as a result of the severe discrimination they have faced in the workplace.
"Having lived a life largely on the margins, in fear of judgement and rejection, it is very difficult for transgender people, especially those over 50, to build a solid, safe social network to rely on," Monopoli explains further. "For obvious reasons, most of us have no children, and our families of origin have often severed all ties."
Beyond those who have disclosed their transsexual identity, there are others who have decided to take their secret to the grave. We will never know how many there are, but the research by Vanessa Fabbre and Anna Siverskog also records elderly people who, calling helplines anonymously, say they fear that someone, upon their death, might find the clothes they have always worn in secret at home.
The diagnosis of gender dysphoria helped me, but I'm still fighting against discrimination from people, especially my family. At 63 I told myself: "All of this has to end, and I fully intend to make it happen."
Tony
The risks of hormone therapies, often self-administered
On a clinical level, several international studies reveal a direct correlation between the use of hormone therapies and the risk of developing metabolic bone and cardiovascular diseases. In addition, factors that are very common among transgender people — such as depression, stress and an unhealthy lifestyle — increase cognitive decline, dementia and the risk of Alzheimer's.
"Scientific research on the prolonged use of hormone therapies is very recent," comments Monopoli. "Until not long ago, hormones were taken without any medical guidance and in constant overdose. There was word of mouth — we knew the names of the drugs and the pharmacies where we could buy them. The doses were massive. We just wanted to achieve the desired results in the shortest time possible. That is why today, in services like Sportello Trans Ala Milano, medical monitoring and assessment are an absolute priority."
"At my age, I'd finally like a bit of peace"
Stefania is a Milanese transsexual woman, very beautiful and youthful-looking — no one would guess she is 68. She invited us into her home to tell us about her life: a daily struggle not to be overwhelmed and to find stability.
"I left home at 17 — back then you didn't come of age until 21. I never had any doubts about my sexual identity, not even as a child. I always felt more female than male," Stefania recounts. "I spent my youth running from police raids in the street while we were working. They would lock us up in the barracks for a night and let us out through the main station the next morning. A parade in broad daylight. It was humiliating, because the police would also confiscate our wigs and people couldn't hold back their comments and judgements. I was assigned Article 1, which classified me as a 'habitual offender' because cross-dressing was considered a crime and I had refused to accept the invitation to 'correct' my behaviour. A persecution that also meant having my driving licence taken away. Those were also the years of the first street demonstrations to claim our rights, supported by the Radical Party with Emma Bonino and Marco Pannella. What saved me were the transsexual women I took as role models; they passed on to me the courage and determination to evolve, to keep improving myself while respecting who I am. Many didn't make it — it only took a heavier humiliation than usual to send them plunging into the abyss of alcohol and drugs."
The fear of loneliness and of not knowing who to turn to
"Now I'm nearly 70 and I'm tired of facing daily difficulties and humiliations, linked above all to people's ignorance and morbid curiosity," Stefania continues. "In the end I decided to start the process of changing my gender identity. There are situations that cisgender people don't think about, but, for example, my bank recently replaced all its staff and at the counter, with a male name on my documents, I feel like a circus animal because they come in a line to stare at me and snigger. It had taken me years to build a 'normal' relationship with the previous staff and now I have to start all over again. The last time I was in hospital
Elderly transgender people, the most vulnerable and hidden
Rights — di Estella Beltramelli
What does it mean to be elderly and transgender? Is society ready to stand by them? We met some transgender women activists who told us their story. There is an invisible population: elderly transgender people.