Endro Martini, geologist: Italy can no longer withstand floods like the one in the Marche

Endro Martini, geologist: Italy can no longer withstand floods like the one in the Marche

Environment · ·

After the Marche flood, geologist Endro Martini warns politicians: “Now is the time to invest in maintenance plans and a cultural shift.”

"In December 2019, a river contract and an action programme were drawn up for the River Misa, which provided for a great many things. Were they carried out? No. So far, only the work on the detention basin has begun (a hydraulic structure that reduces flow during a watercourse's floods through temporary storage, ed.), some light maintenance has been done, the embankments have been reinforced and the new bridge in Senigallia has been built, but then when all hell breaks loose…"

alluvione marche
Rescue workers and volunteers continue their efforts to support the population and restore road access. © Anpas

Endro Martini, geologist, is the coordinator for the Italian Society of Environmental Geology of river contracts, a tool introduced by the environment code in 2006 through which river management is addressed by bringing together all stakeholders, both public and private, and defining a precise planning programme for protection against hydraulic risk.

As well as having been president of the steering committee for Italy Water Forum 2024, the most important international event in the water sector, which brings together the scientific community, businesses, the world of cooperation and civil society to discuss the global challenges of water (Italy's bid came second, beaten by Indonesia), he is a great expert on the rivers of the Marche, including the Misa and the Burano, which were at the centre of the tragic flood of recent days. And in his interview with Lifegate he warns: the events at Senigallia and its surroundings may not have been foreseeable or avoidable, true, but only because Italy does not invest adequately in prevention.

The interview with geologist Endro Martini

Was there really no way to have a more effective early-warning system in the Marche?
What happened in Senigallia — 420 millimetres of water in 4–6 hours, practically a third to a half of the normal annual rainfall — was an exceptional event, at the very limit of what one might expect. Those of my generation will remember the 1996 flood in Versilia (with 440 millimetres of rain in just 8 hours and 13 fatalities, ed.): after periods of drought, this type of event can be triggered. Meteorologists are able to forecast the arrival of a significant weather system, but when self-regenerating phenomena occur (a thunderstorm that feeds itself due to the contrast between two air masses with different thermal characteristics — one warm and humid, the other cold and dry — as happened in the Marche, ed.), it becomes difficult to make an accurate forecast: even advanced technology is not yet capable of it.

Given the damage and the loss of life, isn't it time to act on the prevention of land instability?
I read a survey by Ance, the construction industry association, which estimated an average of 2.5 billion euros per year in damage caused in Italy by floods, landslides and earthquakes, of which we certainly have no shortage in this country… Very calmly, I would like to hope that the new Parliament, with both chambers sitting and a government formed, whatever it may be, will devote one or more days to reflecting on how to counter and mitigate them. When the law on land defence was passed in 1989, urgent three-year interventions were established. We talk so much about economic crises and lack of jobs: well, a public investment, co-financed by the private sector and Europe, that puts 2–3 billion euros a year into projects for major works, but also for light maintenance (the routine cleaning of drains and mowing, which does not require the use of machinery and infrastructure, ed.) and eco-compatible interventions, means creating jobs and managing risk through sustainable development. Can we keep on counting the rescue operations, the damage and the fatalities? We have 500 rivers: if not now, when?

#Ance è al lavoro per aggiornare i dati indispensabili sul #dissestoidrogeologico e per richiamare la politica su temi fondamentali per la salvaguardia dei #cittadini e dei #territori

#RaiRadio3

Have we reached the point of no return?
Our territory is no longer capable of handling events half the magnitude of this one, let alone if events like this are to recur in the future. Today they call them Medicanes — they are, in every respect, small hurricanes. Maintenance is important, it must be continuous and must be done properly, but on its own it is not enough: there is an ecosystem problem that must be maintained and preserved.

In what way?
For example, we need to retain water when too much of it arrives, and perhaps store it, then release it when there is none. We have come through 5 months of drought; the rivers of the Marche were dry, with no water flowing through them. When those millimetres of rain suddenly fell from the sky, a flood wave arrived that swept everything away — even the detention basin construction site suffered enormous damage.

Alluvione nelle Marche
Flood in the Marche, streets in Senigallia reduced to rivers of mud © Lorenzo Brenna

This means adapting to climate change: yet the national plan has been stalled for a few years now, as has the law on land consumption.
The care and management of the territory cannot be approached with the same mindset that created the problems we now have to solve. There is a need for a moment of reflection in the wake of the emergency: that is why I say the new Parliament must dedicate one or two days to hearing all the experts, making decisions, going into the state budget and finding the resources.
There is currently a European consultation on land management: if we don't understand that prevention means saving money… Several days have passed since last Thursday — how much has the emergency cost us between helicopters, volunteers and aid systems? We're probably talking somewhere between 20 and 40 million euros: isn't it better to put that money into the territory to mitigate these events, or must we always wait until after the fact?

🔴 Quando c'è un'allerta per #maltempo è importante fare la cosa giusta 👇
#15settembre

Are you talking about a genuine cultural shift?
I'm talking, on the one hand, about public investment, and on the other, about a top-down cultural revolution. One that also involves giving citizens adequate information. Warning messages must reach people directly on their mobile phones, and not only to the mayor of a small municipality, who is the last link in the chain and the first to be pilloried when they have too little to work with… And then there is self-protection: when it rains, I shouldn't go down to the garage to check on the car — I should go upstairs. I shouldn't drive through an underpass and risk getting trapped there. People need more information. Hotels have signs on their doors with instructions in case of fire. Well: in every home in a flood-risk area there should be a sign saying what to do in the event of a weather alert.

Can we manage to make this shift in pace, possibly in a short time?
Obama used to say 'yes we can', and someone once said 'where there's a will there's a way'. If the will is there, it can be done — we can start right now. Remember the Bisagno, the stream that burst its banks in the Genoa area in 2014? There they drew up an intervention plan, and the works are now nearing completion. What is needed is long-term planning and three-year maintenance plans. We need to start immediately, but we can do it.