Why British salmon farms have lost their organic certification

Why British salmon farms have lost their organic certification

Food · Carlotta Garancini ·

The Soil Association has withdrawn organic certification from British salmon farms for failing to meet environmental and animal welfare standards.

In Great Britain, the certification body Soil Association has announced the withdrawal of organic certification for farmed salmon after 20 years. As the Guardian reports, the association stated that it had found conditions in terms of environmental protection and animal welfare on farms to fall short of its "high standards", and that there are no prospects of rapid change.

allevamento salmoni scozia
Photo: Getty Images

 "When we started working on salmon 20 years ago," said Helen Browning, chief executive of the Soil Association, "we aspired to an aquaculture system capable of applying the principles of organic production at sea. We envisaged a multi-trophic, enriched environment that could provide the resources necessary for a dignified life for salmon, with minimal negative impact on other species. However, progress in this direction has been negligible. The evidence gathered suggests that outcomes in terms of welfare and the environment are not sufficient to allow us to continue."

Why the Soil Association withdrew organic certification from salmon farms

The Soil Association's decision follows accusations that the label amounted to a greenwashing operation at the expense of farmed salmon. For two years, the NGO WildFish has been calling on the association to publish the inspection reports from its salmon farms, under environmental information laws. The association has so far refused, despite a first-instance court order; however, a biennial review conducted by the Soil Association of its "organic"-certified farms found problems relating to animal suffering and high mortality rates, which were not significantly better than those of non-organic farms. 

"It is a first step towards exposing the environmental, sustainability and animal welfare disaster that salmon farming represents," said Nick Measham, chief executive of WildFish, commenting on the Soil Association's decision to withdraw its label.

WildFish: "Salmon farming is incompatible with organic principles"

According to WildFish, salmon farming has always been and will always be antithetical to the principles of organics. The organisation highlights among the issues the use of pesticides and aggressive chemical treatments to combat parasites, coastal water pollution caused by toxic chemicals and organic waste, high fish mortality rates, the impact on the survival of wild salmon, and the unsustainable use of feed produced from wild fish, much of which comes from the coasts of West Africa, resulting in the depletion of fish stocks and the undermining of food security for local populations.

gray fish jumping over body of water surrounded with plants
Salmon farming threatens the survival of wild salmon — Photo: Drew Farwell / Unsplash

The withdrawal of certification could hit the salmon industry

At present, salmon farms enjoy government support: the withdrawal of the Soil Association's certification does not entail the loss of organic recognition under government regulations. Producers have stated that they operate in accordance with some of the highest standards in the world, within a heavily regulated sector that is subject to more than 1,600 audits and inspections every year, and that the industry has invested more than one billion pounds in fish health, environmental performance and new technologies.

The British farmed salmon industry produces around 205,000 tonnes of fish and is worth one billion pounds a year. Salmon is considered the most popular fish among British households, who consume 65,000 tonnes of it a year.

salmone
Photo: Getty Images

"The Soil Association label's endorsement lent salmon farming a kind of hallowed aura," said Tom Appleby, head of governance and legal affairs at Blue Marine Foundation, who considers the withdrawal of certification to be of the utmost importance, as it strikes at the very heart of the salmon farming business model.