Death penalty: Alabama wants to reintroduce gas chambers
Rights — di Maurizio Bongioanni
After three failed executions, Alabama is proposing to replace lethal injections with gas masks. The death penalty risks becoming even more cruel.

After three failed executions, Alabama is proposing to replace lethal injections with gas masks. The death penalty risks becoming even more cruel.
In 2023, the death penalty will become a topic of discussion in the United States. In the year just ended, the state of Alabama attempted to carry out 4 death sentences but only 2 of these achieved their lethal objective: two inmates were "spared", in fact, as a result of – and this really is the right way to put it – botched executions.

The triggering case was the execution of Joe Nathan James, put to death on 28 July at the end of a procedure that lasted more than three hours, during which staff made numerous cuts to the inmate's arm before managing to find a vein and inject the drugs for the lethal injection. James's death prompted death-row inmates in Alabama to file appeals to block executions, arguing that there was a risk of a cruel and therefore unlawful death.
The atrocious death inflicted on James could have been repeated with Kenneth Eugene Smith and Alan Eugene Miller: instead their executions were called off due to the same difficulties in inserting the needles (this frequently happens with inmates who are obese). But Alabama, rather than calling the death penalty itself into question, proposed solving the problem by reintroducing gas chambers.
The journalist Elizabeth Bruenig reported on the macabre intentions of the American state; her work for The Atlantic was translated into Italian by journalist Alessio Marchionna. In reality, these would not be actual gas chambers of the kind used until a few decades ago, when small cells were filled with substances that destroyed inmates' organs.
The current proposal being considered by the conservative American state is to replace oxygen with nitrogen, causing death by hypoxia, a condition of oxygen deficiency at the level of the body's tissues. But, as Bruenig explains, the procedure has never been applied and therefore presents a series of unknowns regarding how condemned prisoners would react.

The death penalty by gas was introduced in the United States in 1921, when it was considered an innovation capable of replacing older and more brutal methods, such as hanging and the electric chair. Gas "promised" a painless and less bloody death, but barely three years after its introduction it became clear that gas reserved an atrocious death for prisoners: a well-known example, recounted by the journalist, is that of Gee Jon, whose sentence was carried out on 8 February 1924.
On that occasion, officials at the Nevada prison where Jon was incarcerated locked the condemned man inside a stone house that had been converted for executions. The space was then flooded with hydrocyanic acid, a gas used to exterminate insects. Jon died after several hours of great suffering, but nothing stopped the use of gas chambers, not even the fact that they were associated with Nazi Germany. The last person to be killed in this way was Walter LaGrand, an inmate from Arizona, in 1999: it took him 18 minutes to die.
Alabama already has a plan ready to answer the critics: rather than sealed rooms filled with gas, the idea involves sealed masks to induce hypoxia in an immobilised inmate. "Nitrogen is cheap and readily available," the journalist explains, "but it is also extremely dangerous. Used in a prison, it could pose a risk to staff in the event of leaks. In 2022, a liquid nitrogen leak at a poultry plant in Georgia caused six deaths and eleven hospitalisations."
Recently, a spokesperson for Airgas, a national industrial gas distributor that has previously done business with the Alabama prison administration, told the journalist that "beyond the philosophical and intellectual debate about capital punishment, supplying nitrogen for executions is not consistent with our company values." Accordingly, "Airgas will not provide Alabama with nitrogen or other inert gases to induce hypoxia for the purpose of human execution." It appears that few suppliers want to be directly involved in America's return to the gas chamber.
Alabama will need a protocol to carry out the first execution by nitrogen hypoxia, and until this autumn state officials did not have one. "It would take a certain boldness to be the first state to test an unknown method of execution, after three consecutive failed executions," Bruenig concludes. She adds, however, that one should not underestimate the boldness of that state's administrators when it comes to putting people to death.