Arpav surveys show that the wells examined contain an emerging substance called Genx. According to Greenpeace, the discharges would have been caused by Miteni. The company defends itself: “the data are not real”.
The Pfas affair, linked to the contamination of groundwater in the Vicenza area and surrounding zones, is certainly far from over. Indeed, the situation appears to be growing even more complicated, given the discovery of a new substance known as Genx — or Hfpo-Da, or 2,3,3,3-tetrafluoro-2-(heptafluoropropoxy)propanoic acid — a fluorinated surfactant that is reportedly used by industry as a replacement for Pfoa in the production of Teflon. Surveys carried out by the Regional Environmental Protection Agency (Arpav) showed that it "has been detected at several groundwater monitoring points in the immediate vicinity of the Miteni plant in Trissino and, in modest quantities, at a number of wells located a few kilometres downstream of the production site".
The first samplings in schools in the Padua area to analyse Pfas levels. Photo Greenpeace
Greenpeace's accusations over Genx
A few days later, Greenpeace, which has long been monitoring the contaminated water situation in Veneto, made public a report — Sette scomode verità sul Genx — explaining that "from 2014 to 2017, Miteni of Trissino, having obtained authorisation from the Veneto Region to treat hazardous chemical waste, received from the Netherlands every year — and specifically from the chemical company Du Pont (today Chemours) — confirmed quantities of up to 100 tonnes per year of hazardous chemical waste containing Genx".
"It is paradoxical that a company already known as the main source of Pfas contamination should deliberately be granted by regional authorities, with negligence and recklessness, the possibility of disposing of hazardous chemical waste without inserting any kind of limit on Genx discharges, and from the treatment of which enormous quantities of waste are generated," stated Giuseppe Ungherese, head of Greenpeace Italia's pollution campaign, in a press release. "Quantities that a territory already severely affected by one of the most significant environmental pollution events in Europe would certainly have wanted and should have been able to avoid."
What is Genx
It is a next-generation substance on which there is still limited scientific evidence, some of it published by the manufacturing companies themselves. However, Greenpeace writes that "based on data released by the Dutch National Institute of Public Health and the Environment (Rivm) in 2016, Genx can be classified as a persistent substance (as can other Pfas)", and that "while demonstrating a lesser negative effect on the reproductive system, Genx could be potentially carcinogenic".
The Region therefore moved quickly to remedy the situation, backed by citizens' committees, calling for the suspension of all the company's active plants, assessing the "need for the Province of Vicenza to issue a formal injunction against Miteni to carry out (within 30 days of the date of the injunction itself) checks on the integrity and functionality of all the systems present at the Miteni site. The aim of these checks is to ascertain any possible leakage of products from the company that may be contaminating the water table." At the same time, however, it criticised the environmental association's claims, through the words of regional environment councillor Gianpaolo Bottacin: "Greenpeace is making statements that do not correspond to the truth. One cannot throw out unfounded accusations of negligence and recklessness with impunity, when Veneto was the first to open the way in bringing to light and tackling unprecedented environmental issues, such as Pfas."
Miteni's reply
On its official page, the company explains that in Trissino there is "one of the few plants in the world with the necessary technologies", used to regenerate Genx — "a substance used for Teflon in place of Pfoa. Processing ended on 1 July, because the law sets strict deadlines for completing it."
Meanwhile, on the pages of VicenzaToday, the company explains that "the association cites theoretical capacity figures that have nothing to do with the real ones, which are significantly lower. For example, in some years no Genx processing was carried out whatsoever — zero. One hundred tonnes have never arrived in Trissino in the entire history of processing the molecule. Continuing to throw numbers around at random to cause a stir is irresponsible."
What emerges is that the environmental situation of Veneto's river basins — and beyond — is far from being under control. In one of Italy's and Europe's most active industrial areas, where everything is produced, thousands of tonnes of chemical products continue and will continue to arrive. They should be managed in compliance with regulations and in the interests of citizens' health.
No peace for Veneto's waters. After Pfas, here comes Genx
Environment — di Rudi Bressa
Arpav surveys show that the wells examined contain an emerging substance called Genx. According to Greenpeace, the discharges would have been caused by Miteni. The company defends itself: “the data are not real”.